Scott Peters asked Faulconer and Zapf to request city attorney Mara Elliott investigate North Chapel make-over.
  • Scott Peters asked Faulconer and Zapf to request city attorney Mara Elliott investigate North Chapel make-over.
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it

The gloves are off at San Diego city hall as mayor Kevin Faulconer and fellow Republican Lorie Zapf discover that newly empowered Democrats are not likely to play nice, given their new House majority in Washington and supermajority control of the city council here.

SOHO questioning commercial use of former NTC chapel.

SOHO questioning commercial use of former NTC chapel.

As reported by the Union-Tribune November 10, La Jolla Democratic House member Scott Peters fired off a November 5 letter to the mayor and his now-defeated GOP council ally Zapf demanding a city attorney investigation of major Republican giver McMillin Companies.

At stake is a plan by McMillin for the North Chapel at Point Loma's former Naval Training Center, now known as Liberty Station, which was turned over by GOP mayor Susan Golding and the council to the National City developer in June 1999 after backstage campaign finance skullduggery undermined another developer recommended by the city manager and a blue-ribbon citizens committee.

Now McMillin is said to be seeking to convert the North Chapel into an eatery and wedding venue, drawing heat from neighbors and preservationists, while simultaneously shopping its 66-acre master lease of the former Navy property to other owners.

“Several members of the community, including Save Our Heritage Organisation, have been in contact with my office to express their concerns regarding the leasings by the McMillin Company (or a successor in interest) of the North Chapel to a commercial tenant, which they claim violates the Guidelines for the Treatment of Historic Properties at the Naval Training Center,” wrote Peters in a letter to the mayor and Zapf.

The congressman asked Faulconer and Zapf to make a request to city attorney Mara Elliott, a Democrat, to trigger an official investigation of the matter. Faulconer instead referred the issue to his staff and Zapf was noncommittal, the paper reported.

The Republican pair has benefited from money furnished by McMillin owners and executives, city disclosure filings show, with Faulconer the top beneficiary and Zapf, who lost her November reelection battle to Democrat Jen Campbell, not far behind.

Since June 2009, Faulconer has collected a total of $21,999 in campaign cash from McMillin employees, making him the biggest overall beneficiary of the developer's support during the period, according to the records.

Zapf's city council campaigns have received a total of $9000 since March 2010 from donors employed by McMillin, giving the lame-duck councilwoman less incentive, it is widely believed, to seek an investigation of the company by the Democratic city attorney.

Republicans have historically received the most city hall campaign cash from McMillin executives, including Faulconer predecessor Jerry Sanders, with $9185, city councilman Carl DeMaio's failed 2012 bid for mayor, getting $8275, and the GOP Lincoln Club, with $7325. GOP ex-city attorney Jan Goldsmith's cause picked up $6300 and Bonnie Dumanis's 2012 run for mayor received $4900.

Over the years, Democrats have managed to pick up smaller amounts of backing from McMillin employees, including former city councilman Todd Gloria, now in the state Assembly, with $2910, and city councilwoman Myrtle Cole, defeated for reelection this month, who received a total of $850 from two McMillin executives in 2015 for her legal defense fund.

Current city attorney Elliott's campaign fund got $500 from McMillin chairman Scott McMillin in January 2017, following her election in November 2016. From January 2007 through November of last year, McMillin contributions to city hall hopefuls added up $113,802, per city data.

  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it


Cassander Nov. 12, 2018 @ 2:05 p.m.

About time someone in office got serious about this. Out of all the buildings here, this chapel and the HQ building are the only ones set aside for use as originally intended in the NTC Master Plan—and McMillin can't do even one decent thing in appreciation for getting this public land free by honoring this commitment.

All the other ways they have screwed us over and reneged on promises with Liberty Station may not be legally enforceable, but this sure as hell is. And I hope it opens up the whole history of McMillin's dirty dealings to further scrutiny.


AlexClarke Nov. 14, 2018 @ 6:09 a.m.

This is just another example of how incompetent the city administration is. It is also an prime example of how corrupt developers are when dealing with the city. You just can't fix stupid.


Visduh Nov. 14, 2018 @ 10 a.m.

That piece of property was a crown jewel, and a once-in-a-city-lifetime opportunity for reuse. Why did it have to be handed over to a single developer? While the slobberin' city might have made a botch of some things it did with the area, the decisions would/could/should have had plenty of public scrutiny, and would have been subject to voter influence. Instead we got this second-string developer with its short-sighted reuse plans, and a greedy one to boot. Thank you Susan Golding and your sycophantic council.


Geranium Nov. 14, 2018 @ 6:14 p.m.

Maybe its a good sign that Scott Peters, as part of his potential mayoral run, has opened up a dialog about the corrupt and long relationship between the City government and developers. Perhaps his consultants and his gut tells him this is something he can use as part of his campaign. As we know, the cozy relationship between developers and our "leaders" has been equal opportunity corruption, involving both Republicans and Democrats. So maybe he realizes this could give him an edge over other potential Democratic candidates.

Is it too much to imagine a City government that is focused on governing for the residents instead of playing monopoly with the powerful.


Sign in to comment

Let’s Be Friends

Subscribe for local event alerts, concerts tickets, promotions and more from the San Diego Reader