Deanna Lorson:  "It is generally more cost effective to pay overtime ."
  • Deanna Lorson: "It is generally more cost effective to pay overtime ."
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it

Did NBC-7’s report about overtime paid by the city of Oceanside cause heads to roll?

On July 3, Alex Presha reported that the Oceanside paid out $3.86 million in police overtime. Some officers made more in overtime than their regular pay. One officer who makes $91,000 took home $160,000 in additional overtime. Presha disclosed that 173 Public Works and Water Utilities department employees made more than $600,000 alone in overtime, including a supervisor who got an extra $30,000 plus a regular salary of $84,000.

Ex-Marine Christopher Rodriguez has been holding fundraisers.

Ex-Marine Christopher Rodriguez has been holding fundraisers.

NBC-7’s Presha reported that city manager Michelle Skaggs Lawrence declined to comment to him about the overtime. Less than a week after the report, Oceanside Mayor Peter Weiss declared an emergency city council meeting to announce the surprise resignation of Skaggs Lawrence.

City hall insiders say the move was tied to the illness of Skaggs Lawrence’s father and she had been discussing a retirement for months. The timing of her retirement was coincidental with the overtime piece.

Esther Sanchez: “I lost it.”

Esther Sanchez: “I lost it.”

On August 21 it was announced that the city council had agreed to offer assistant city manager Deanna Lorson a contract for employment to serve as city manager at its September 11 meeting.

Lorson explains that overtime is not such a bad thing. “…It is generally more cost effective to pay overtime than hire additional staff, due to the cost of benefits – primarily retirement…As long as employees are willing to work additional hours and supervisors are ensuring that employees get adequate rest/breaks and are not getting burned out.”

Councilwoman Esther Sanchez says the pool of applicants who want to join the Oceanside police force has been getting smaller while calls for service has almost doubled, and that current policemen have to respond to needs of the city. “I understand we have 15 [police department] vacancies right now.” Sanchez says that now that possession of meth and heroin has been de-criminalized, the presence of users on the streets has increased which in turns adds time burdens on Oceanside police.

Melba Bishop had an Oceanside park named after her before she died in 2015.

Melba Bishop had an Oceanside park named after her before she died in 2015.

Skaggs Lawrence’s departure is one of the few times in the last 45 years that the Oceanside city manager left without open antagonism or under a cloud of controversy.

Larry Bagley happened to be city manager in 1975 when the city suffered a downtown race riot and endured national publicity as a tawdry, rundown Marine town, leading to his departure. In the 80s managers Suzanne Foucault and Tom Wilson were publicly chastised at meetings or the press by councilmembers. Steve Jepsen had two terms as city manager, the first was derailed after charges that he helped cut corners for a developer who was a heavy campaign contributor to Mayor Terry Johnson. When John Mamaux’s one-year contract was not renewed in 1991, he sued. Mamaux claimed the council majority forced him to do unethical acts. Mamaux claimed a council majority had no right not to offer him another contract. He received an out-of-court settlement.

The Oceanside City Council, once thought to be so contentious that it actually hurt the city’s ability to do business, seems to have mellowed in recent years. Oceanside politics first became a blood sport in 1981 when newly elected councilwoman Melba Bishop spearheaded a successful recall of councilmen Ray Burgess and Bill Bell and got two friends elected.

Ten years later Bishop herself was the subject of a recall. A picture of Mayor Larry Bagley wearing a cap that said “Save the Whales - Harpoon Melba” [a full-figured woman] made the front page of the North County Blade-Citizen. The recall ultimately failed but the year-long campaign was thought to cost Bishop her re-election in 1992. The much loved/hated political mastermind had an Oceanside park named after her before she died in 2015.

Current Oceanside council members do not publicly wish their colleagues would get impaled with a whaling spear. But the undercurrents of an upcoming mayoral election seemed to have bubbled up at a June council meeting.

Nineteen-year city council veteran Esther Sanchez, a Democrat, has announced her run for next year’s mayoral election, and insiders say they expect that she will face gun rights proponent Republican ex-Marine Christopher Rodriguez who was just elected last year. Rodriguez has not yet announced, but he has been holding fundraisers.

At a council meeting two months ago, Sanchez lashed out at Rodriguez when he suggested that his salary be increased. “I lost it,” admits Sanchez about her reaction to Rodriguez’s suggestion that council members get paid as full-time employees. “This is a public service. It is embarrassing that anyone on this dais would vote to say give me more money,” she said at the time.

Sanchez says that San Diego is the only city out of 18 countywide that have full-time councilmembers. “I am absolutely astounded we would consider that for even half a second.”

The other announced candidate for mayor is former councilman and state assemblyman Rocky Chavez, which means that all three major candidates for Oceanside mayor would be of Hispanic descent. “Oceanside is a very welcoming city, and I think this is in part because of the diversity of the population and the influence of Camp Pendleton," says Lorson.

Lorson is the third woman to run Oceanside in 30 years. “San Diego has many women serving as city manager and Oceanside mirrors this trend.”

  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it

Comments

AlexClarke Aug. 27, 2019 @ 5:26 p.m.

So what is the point of this article? Is it that overtime should not be paid? Or that people who work well past their normal shift should not earn additional money? Or that the City should not pay overtime? No matter how well you manage a police department they can not predict or control what happens. Police respond to calls for service. What does Ken Leighton think should be done? Maybe police overtime should be limited and when they run out of hours not show up to calls? Same with water utility workers. No overtime means that they will get around to the problem as soon as they can get someone there who is not on overtime. It seems that if someone working by the hour gets overtime it amount to some kind of crime. Cops, firemen/women, utility workers, etc. sell their time and skill by the hour and if you don't want them to respond then send them home at the end of eight hours and deal with the problem yourself.

0

Socks3742 Aug. 27, 2019 @ 5:53 p.m.

I'm not a journalist, but I've always thought the point of any article is to advise the general public as to what's going on. Why do people over analyze? I just read the article, and take it for what it's worth. To each his own.

0

AlexClarke Aug. 28, 2019 @ 7:27 a.m.

Ok, I get it. Ken Leighton tends to be anti-labor when he reports on public employees. Maybe I did over analyze however no one has ever accused me of that.

0

Ken Leighton Aug. 27, 2019 @ 7:20 p.m.

Dear Socks- I'm not an anonymous blogger, but I've always thought the point of any anonymous blog was to have some basic point or premise. Why do anonymous bloggers even bother to scrutinize or analyze? This article brought out the following points: Oceanside city government has a history of being backstabbing and it appears that it is getting less so. Also, Oceanside city managers have usually been fired after an ugly public display. This appears to be changing. Also, the political landscape for Oceanside mayor was outlined as it has never been done before in any other media, outlining the three major players as it stands right now. Why do anonymous bloggers over analyze? Why do anonymous bloggers even exist? To each his own.

0

Socks3742 Aug. 27, 2019 @ 11:18 p.m.

Dear Ken - I was referring to Alex as the "over analyzer." He was criticizing your article, and I didn't feel that way. Perhaps I wasn't very clear. I didn't hit reply to his comment because I don't like "online arguments." I prefer getting along. All opinions should be respected. Thanks for your comment.

0

Visduh Aug. 27, 2019 @ 7:49 p.m.

Alex, the point of this article is to once again inform the voters--those who might care enough to appreciate knowing--what is going on in that sorry city. The city council has been known as the "snake pit" or the "pit of vipers" for far too long, and nothing seems to change. City managers come and go, usually under a cloud. The PD is one of the weakest in the county, and has had a history of discrimination and harassment claims. The current police chief should have been replaced years ago. And so it goes. Now we learn that the PD and other departments pay huge overtime and then justify it on the basis that it is cheaper (!) than hiring more cops and employees. Heard enough? It gets worse the deeper you dig. It seems that no matter who is elected in the seaside city, the results never improve.

That's the point.

0

AlexClarke Aug. 28, 2019 @ 7:30 a.m.

Agreed. I will point out that the residents of Oceanside voted for every one of the "pit of vipers". They deserve the government they vote for. It is the folks in the "snake pit" that chose the City Managers and confirm the Police Chief.

0

themanthemyththelegend Aug. 29, 2019 @ 11:11 a.m.

It more than likely is cheaper, since you are not adding more bodies that will collect 95% of their highest pay for the rest of their lives. Since you don't have any numbers to prove your point, and since most police departments nationwide operate this way, I will defer to the operational experts for correctness, and your argument as yet another example of "Well it should be this way.." episode 1000 featuring you and your cohort Alex Clarke that both you consistently employ.

0

Visduh Sept. 4, 2019 @ 5:58 p.m.

I am too, although we disagree often.

0

Cherrywilson Aug. 28, 2019 @ 12:22 a.m.

This comment was removed by the site staff for violation of the usage agreement.

0

fredluis Sept. 2, 2019 @ 12:28 a.m.

This comment was removed by the site staff for violation of the usage agreement.

0

Sign in to comment

Let’s Be Friends

Subscribe for local event alerts, concerts tickets, promotions and more from the San Diego Reader

Close