Whoa back, SANDAG, whoa back (Colin Parent)
  • Whoa back, SANDAG, whoa back (Colin Parent)
  • Story alerts
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it

The long-controversial transit plan inching toward implementation by the San Diego Association of Governments, dubbed San Diego Forward, could actually move the city backward when it comes to meeting pollution goals set by its own Climate Action Plan.

So say Circulate San Diego and Climate Action Campaign, activist groups that held a joint press conference Wednesday (September 23) announcing the release of a new report contrasting the transit goals of SANDAG's and the city's plans.

Not Even Close

"Not only is transportation important for economic development, lifestyle, and social equity, it's a crucial component in reducing the risk of climate change," says Colin Parent, lead study author and counsel for Circulate San Diego. "Some of the mobility strategies outlined in the climate plan must be implemented on a regional level by SANDAG, not by the city alone.

"Unfortunately, SANDAG is preparing a transportation plan that could be a barrier to San Diego accomplishing its climate goals."

Under the city's plan, 50 percent of residents living in "transit corridors" within a half-mile of a light-rail station or in an area well served by transit, walking, and cycling amenities are expected to rely on one of these methods for most trips by 2035. This includes 25 percent bus and trolley ridership, 7 percent commuting on foot, and 18 percent using a bicycle to get around.

By contrast, SANDAG envisions only 8.6 percent transit ridership in the same span (up from 5.1 percent at present). The number of pedestrians and cyclists is expected to remain virtually unchanged over the next 20 years, with just over 4 percent of the city's population along transit corridors expected to walk and 2 percent expected to travel by bike.

"SANDAG's projections show that it's mathematically impossible for the City of San Diego to achieve its transit goals using the network they're currently planning. SANDAG has to meet the city halfway, and they're not even close," argues Parent.

Can't Be World-Class

Nicole Capretz, Climate Action Campaign's executive director and study co-author, echoed Parent's concerns and joined in a call urging the city's representatives to SANDAG (mayor Kevin Faulconer and councilmember Todd Gloria) to "use the power of the bully pulpit" to push the regional organization to allocate more resources for alternatives to car-reliant transportation, a cause also championed by other local activists.

"We cannot be a world-class city without a world-class transportation system," Capretz said. "We may be on the cusp of passing one of the most ambitious climate plans in the nation, yet setting ourselves up for failure," due to SANDAG's "thumbing their nose at the city's climate plan.

"What we imagine is that our mayor and council vote 'no' on this regional transportation plan, unless and until there is more investment and resources dedicated to building the necessary infrastructure to make people feel safe in walking and taking public transit to work."

The latest revision to the SANDAG plan, released after the initial plan was struck down by the courts in 2012, is expected to come up for a vote before boardmembers including Faulconer and Gloria on October 9. The city, meanwhile, is expected to vote on its climate plan sometime in December.

  • Story alerts
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it


jnojr Sept. 24, 2015 @ 10:58 a.m.

I love the picture. A small group of idiots espousing transportation methods that cannot work in San Diego. I cannot ride a bike to work. I cannot take a bus or a train or a trolley.


pjamason2 Sept. 25, 2015 @ 3:18 p.m.

If it can't work, then how did a record number of people ride public transit in San Diego last year? Younger Americans are increasingly seeking cities with transit options. Just because alternative transit doesn't work for you, don't assume that applies to everyone else.

San Diego ocean temps are their warmest in 85 years and 2014 & 2015 are the warmest air temp years on record globally. How would you address the climate change that's already happening as a result of our auto emissions?


jnojr Sept. 25, 2015 @ 4:26 p.m.

A "record number" means nothing. If five people took a bus last year and six rode this year, that would be a "record number". But the record is still a tiny segment of the population.

You seem to be laboring under the idea that people are deliberately driving cars because they hate the environment and want to enrich Saudi oil princes. But we need to be able to get to our jobs and then home again. Buses only work for a few people. It's great that there are some cities that have buses or trains or whatever that work for more people, but San Diego is not one of them.

You want me to ride a bike 35 miles each way in 80 degree weather to get to and from work? You're nuts. It would take me hours and I'd be stinking and sweaty. I'd spend all day puffing away on a bike, and for what? Sorry, no. I, and most people, will stick with convenient air-conditioned cars until there's a FEASIBLE alternative. I'll be happy to take some kind of mass transportation that will pick me up when I'm ready to go, take me to work in a reasonable amount of time, let me run my errands, then go home when I'm ready to go home. Let me know when that happens. Until then, save it... most people cannot ride bikes or take buses to work. Period.


Sign in to comment

Let’s Be Friends

Subscribe for local event alerts, concerts tickets, promotions and more from the San Diego Reader