• Story alerts
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it

The image above is actually the film's second opening shot. It's the opening of chapter one in the story. What comes before is a prologue.

The prologue opens with a shot of an utterly calm sea at dawn. Tranquility itself, all gentle grays and pinks and even gentler laps and ripples. Quite a contrast with the opening line of the voiceover: "I'm sorry." Uh-oh. Something's wrong.


All Is Lost ***

The camera pans very slowly to the left, and we find out just what that something is (and also, what that tranquil sea is lapping against): a red steel shipping container. Half-sunk but still afloat, It rises from the water like an artificial iceberg, looming higher and higher as the camera pans across its bulk. Here it is, the very bad thing, the thing that should not be there, the thing we could not anticipate that disturbs our peace and contentment. Here is disaster in the face of all our plans. Here is death in the face of all our pleasures.

That is what leads us to the shot above: Robert Redford, the captain of his own boat and seemingly the master of his own fate, a man of means and skill, woken suddenly from a comfortable sleep by unanticipated, random, nightmarish disaster. Water is pouring into his boat, carrying with it, of all things, a child's shoe. How absurd. And yet, we have already heard him say "I'm sorry" to an unnamed someone whom he has failed. We know that it took the threat of death to make him assess his life and try to make amends. We know already that "all is lost" is what had to happen for something to be found.

  • Story alerts
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it


eastlaker Oct. 31, 2013 @ 11:03 p.m.

Must admit that I found myself criticizing the man for the slowness of his reaction to all the challenges, and thinking he should have been better prepared, but of course, that would have been a very different story! His deliberate pace seemed to underline the enormity of what he was up against. Flawed thinking, the result of the impossibility of the situation, lack of water, sleep, food--or the character's intrinsic lack of self-knowledge and his own limitations?

The cinematography was excellent.

Of course, I had to wonder why there was no emergency signal when the raft opened up. I thought that automatically triggers a radio signal that can be picked up from very far away. But I could be wrong, or it was an older model raft!


Sign in to comment

Win a $25 Gift Card to
The Broken Yolk Cafe

Join our newsletter list

Each newsletter subscription means another chance to win!