"F$#@ THE POOR!" --From History Of The World Part One, written and directed by Mel Brooks.

It seems to me that folks have a major league problem in dealing with those less well off. How else can you explain the fact that when budgets are tight, the first programs that get chopped are those dealing with our most vulnerable citizens--the unemployed, the disabled, kids, and the homeless, to name but a few.

Case in point--unemployment insurance bennies. Currently, Federal law allows for up to 99 weeks of UI benefits. Anybody who gets UI benefits knows that their checks rest on a thin edge...they have to mail in (via snail-mail) their claim forms every two weeks, be honest on their answer sheets, and provide "proof of looking" if required.

UI bennies, in reality, cannot fill the person's full finamcial needs (about 2/3rds). So, those of us who recieve them are not living high on the hog, as it were. By keeping our needs modest, we can get by--even as we scan Craigslist, Yahoo Hot Jobs, and other places to find that chimera-for-today: a job that pays properly.

And yet, I have seen two articles (one by Ruben Navarrette in the SD U-T) that somehow are of the notion that long-term UI bennies contribute to high unemployment rates, and that some form of "tough-love" for UI recipients might be in order here. Do what President Clinton did with folks on the AFDC rolls, goes the reasoning, and watch the unemployment rate go down fast!

Obviously, that load of Bravo-Sierra's odor rivals that of the Harris Ranch Feedlot on I-5 at the Coalinga exit, in that you can smell it for miles. The truth is that many of we, the unemployed, would love to get back to work--if there is truly work to be found that pays better than minimum wage and isn't a make-work "McJob."

In my case, my choices are limited. Janitorial deployment is out, due to the fact I have a severe allergy to two industrial cleaners (Spitfire and Triad). With my skin condition, food service work is, by law, forbidden to me. Same with agricultural work, grocery work...anything to do with the handling of food.

I still have my Guard Card, and constantly check out Craigslist, YHJ, and Employment Guide.com for leads. However, with my Federal Jury Service coming up next month, it makes no real sense to apply...unless the employer-in-question can wait a month while I do my service to Uncle Sam. Not very likely.

It's rather obvious that those who propose "tough-love"-like strategies in dealing with any situation such as being unemployed have never been there! And their advocacy of such "Champange Charlie" Reaganomic drivel is done at their peril. For all that it takes for them to change their tune is to see their job go by the boards, exhaust their savings, and not be able to find a job in their field of expertise.

Then they, I daresay, will be prostrate before their chosen diety, thanking Them for that check from the State that allows them to keep looking for work. Hubris, indeed, breeds nemesis. When you combine the hubris of antiphathy for those who are less well-off than you with the "Pre-Quad-Ghost (Jacob Marley, plus the three ghosts of Chirstmas, btw) Visit" attitude of Ebenezer Scrooge? You will find that the nemesis being spawned will show you the same mercy that you showed the last person you snarled "GET A JOB, LOSER!" at on the streets of San Diego--or anywhere else!



CuddleFish April 27, 2010 @ 8:53 p.m.

I mean, there will always be some scammers and mingers and prima donnas who won't just take any job, would prefer to live off the system however meagerly. However, in comparison to corporate and defense industry welfare, I would venture to say this very rich country can afford to carry a few at the bottom, particularly in hard times like these.


Joaquin_de_la_Mesa May 4, 2010 @ 12:19 p.m.

Maybe the opening quote for this post should have been Christian Bale's line in American Psycho, "Get a goddam job!" The government doesn't owe you anything. (And cuddlefish, the government doesn't exist to "carry" anybody.)

Stop labeling yourself "unemployed," LPR. Stop listing the reasons you can't get a job and start thinking about how you could. Start thinking of your welfare as your own responsibility.


Robert Johnston May 19, 2010 @ 8:46 p.m.

In response to #2: First off the bat, what makes you think that I'm NOT looking for employment? Even while I'm waiting for "the call-up that may not happen (Federal Jury Service, which I am liable for until 4-Jun-10), I still scan my daily Yahoo in-box version of Employment Guide for anything I can handle. plus, I make daily scans of Craigslist, Snag-A-Job, and other sites. I even have an application in with walmart for a part-time greeter's position. Plus, my resume is up-to-date--and it stays that way.

Second, it seems rather obvious that you have never walked a mile in my shoes. Your commentary about "thinking about your welfare as your own responsibility" seems rather snide, and obviously ignorant. If I were truly not thinking of my welfare as my own responsibility, I'd still be living in a damn board-and-care, with no ambitions other than to eat, sleep, and poop. Sure, I may get SSDI (Social Security Disabilty Insurance) bennies--but I earned them! It is because I have them that I do live on my own, have food in my fridge, and clothing to wear. Having a part-time job puts extra jingle in my pocket and pays for other needs, certainly. Plus the intangibles of getting out and meeting people carries just as much as the paycheck I recieved twice-a-month, when I was "in the workforce."

Third--using that Christian Bale quote in my thread is a major "no can do" in my book. I do remember something in the Ten Commandments about not taking The Lord's Name In Vain--and that is a line I NEVER cross, both for moral and ethical reasons.

To sum up what I am talking about, Mr. de la Mesa: Before you dare judge me as irresponsible, and pull that reeking Limburger "Get A Job, Get a Life, And Quit Your Snivelling, Loser!" line on me? You might want to step out of your world for a few minutes. Maybe even give your position a good re-think. I have been where you are, fellow--and you can just as easily become like me (and I would not wish THAT on my worst enemy)!

The SSDI bennies I get every month may sate my hunger, but the cheese I buy with proceeds from a job taste that much better! That's a good enough reason to keep plugging away until I re-enter the workforce...a day that I actually look forward to!

Give what I have said a good think, sir. I hate unleashing like this upon a fellow blogger, but your comments could not go unchallenged!



Sign in to comment

Win a $25 Gift Card to
The Broken Yolk Cafe

Join our newsletter list

Each newsletter subscription means another chance to win!