• News Ticker alerts

The City continues to pay the female victims assaulted by former San Diego police officer Anthony Arrevalos. The newest payout will come Tuesday, when city councilmembers will be asked to authorize the city comptroller to issue a check to a San Diego woman for $675,000.

Of course, the settlement did not come without a fight from the City.

The assault occurred on October 22, 2010 when the woman pulled out of a parking garage on Fourth Avenue in downtown. That's when Arevalos turned on his police lights.

Arevalos questioned the Plaintiff and then, according to court documents, he “made personal and crude sexually suggestive remarks about [her] body and groped her breasts with his hand while she was sitting in her car with the car door open. Arevalos also said he was going to arrest her for DUI, but that she could avoid this if she showed her bare breasts to him and let him put his hand down her pants and touch her sexually.”

Five months later, during the investigation, the woman, known as Melissa W., was interviewed by San Diego Police Detective Steve Bernier. It was then that Bernier advised her to wait until after the criminal case was resolved before pursuing a civil case. She was not informed, however, that there was a six-month statute of limitations to file a claim with the City.

So, Melissa W. waited until November 2011, after she testified against Arevalos in court.

But on November 28, the City informed her that her claim had been rejected.

"The claim you presented to the Honorable Mayor and City Council of the City of San Diego on 11/15/2011, is being returned because it was not presented within the 6 (six) months after the event or occurrence as required by law," read the letter from a City claims representative.

Melissa W. proceeded with the case. She presented emails from Detective Bernier where he admitted telling her it was best to wait.

"I apologize," wrote Detective Bernier in a December 6 email. "I am not familiar with the statute of limitations on civil cases. I have seen cases where a victim has filed a civil suit and it has hurt the criminal case. I didn't intend on you missing the opportunity on filing a civil suit."

Despite the admission, from May 2012 to October 2012, the City made several attempts to have the case thrown out.

"In this case, there is no dispute the claim accrued on October 22, 2010," reads one such motion. "Thus, Plaintiff should have filed her government claim on or before April 22, 2011. She did not do so. If Plaintiff wishes to pursue her claim, she should have filed an application to file a late claim on or before October 22, 2011. However, she did not do so. Instead, she waited until April 17, 2012, to file an application for leave to file a late claim, which the City denied as untimely. (Compl. ¶ 24, Ex. 3.) Under these circumstances, this Court does not have jurisdiction to hear Plaintiff’s first claim for relief."

The judge agreed with the City on the timing, however, ruled that the Plaintiff's decision was influenced by a person of authority.

Now, after one year of legal wrangling, the City Attorney's office has given up and has agreed to pay $675,000 from the City's Public Liability Fund.

  • News Ticker alerts


SurfPuppy619 Nov. 9, 2012 @ 12:19 p.m.

I would FIRE the gov agent that authorized that denial. FIRE them, of course there is no accountability in gov.

I never would have filed this case in state court to start with-she should have went straight into Federal US District Court where there is no SOL on civil rights violations, and that 6 month state time limit gets laughed out of federal court everytime a state muni brings it up, which is almost 100% of the time for some reason.


sihan Nov. 17, 2012 @ 12:16 p.m.

you seem to be knowledgeable - I have exactly same case - cops predators citizen prey , where can I go ? how to get to Federal US District Court ?? please contact me , need info how to find me ?


Dorian Hargrove Nov. 9, 2012 @ 12:31 p.m.

I hear you, SurfPuppy. It was surprising to see the lengths that the City Attorney's office went to try and get this case dismissed. It would be different -- not saying it would be justified -- if this wasn't one of the people who testified in court against Arevalos.


SurfPuppy619 Nov. 9, 2012 @ 10:14 p.m.

The is no vicarious liability as a general rule against state/muni agencies, UNLESS they were on notice of the misconduct, which WAS the case here. The SDPD and the City had numerous warnings and complaints on this cop, they were therefor liable for failing to discipline and fire the dirty cop, and what Goldsmith and his Secret Squirrel toupee did is a disgrace, and it doesn't matter if she was or was not a witness against the dirty cop, the City IS liable, and trying to weasel out on a technicality that they themselves caused is the bottom of the barrel and calls into question Goldsmiths ethics and leadership. Goldsmith should be fired.


Visduh Nov. 10, 2012 @ 8:01 p.m.

This sort of fiasco isn't limited to San Diego. All round the nation there are "police" forces that fail to police their own ranks. So the clownish SDPD once again drops the ball and allows a bad guy to sully its reputation. Nothing all that new there. Just think of how many potholes that three quarters of a million could fill, or how many burnt out street lights it could replace, or how many broken sprinkler heads in parks it could fix, or how many embarrassing water main or sewer breaks it could prevent.

But in SD, the cops come first, second and third when it comes to doling out the bucks, and still they cannot keep the creeps out of the ranks. But the cops don't pay, the long-suffering taxpayers do.


SurfPuppy619 Nov. 10, 2012 @ 11:09 p.m.

...and still they cannot keep the creeps out of the ranks. That is b/c these jobs are not filled on merit, but on nepotism, cronyism and affirmative action hires, all of which accounts for a large majority of all city and municipal hiring.


Sign in to comment

Win a $25 Gift Card to
The Broken Yolk Cafe

Join our newsletter list

Each newsletter subscription means another chance to win!