• News Ticker alerts

A judge said the behavior of a Carlsbad housewife immediately after her husband was shot tended to show consciousness of guilt, rather than justifiable homicide. Judge Robert Kearney also noticed that the deceased was shot from behind, at the end of a hearing yesterday in San Diego’s North County Superior Courthouse.

Defendant Julie Elizabeth Harper, 39, was ordered to stand trial for murder in the death of her husband, Jason Harper, 39. The deceased man was a math teacher and occasional volleyball coach at Carlsbad High School, and was found dead from a single gunshot wound last summer, August 7, 2012.

Privately retained defense attorney Paul Pfingst suggested that Julie Harper was fearful of her husband, and he said their children confirmed to investigators that the couple had loud arguments. Julie Harper had recently filed paperwork for a divorce.

Prosecutor Keith Watanabe brought evidence showing that immediately after the shooting, Julie Harper put their three children into her minivan and went around the neighborhood trying to find someone who would take in her kids for a “playday.” At least two neighborhood women declined. Julie then went to Knuckleheads Gym and PlayWerx, places where children can play while parents supervise. After 1 p.m. Julie took her children to her sister’s home near La Jolla; this sister testified it was an unpleasant surprise when Julie quickly left for an “errand” and did not return until almost 10 p.m. At that time Julie came with her father and picked up the children and drove to downtown San Diego to meet with a criminal defense attorney.

The alleged murder weapon has not been found, according to prosecutor Watanabe.

Police found the husband’s body after attorney Paul Pfingst phoned and told them to do a “welfare check” at the home on Badger Lane in Carlsbad. That was after 11 p.m., the same day of the shooting.

Julie Harper’s father testified that Julie and her three children stayed with him at his home in Scripps Ranch the night of August 7, 2012. The father, John Cihak, said when police came to his door several times he did not answer because he “didn’t want to.” John Cihak said he was awaiting instructions from the attorney who was “handling Julie’s problem.” Julie surrendered to police about 3 p.m. the day after the shooting, on August 8, at her father’s home.

Testimony suggested that Jason Harper and his extended family believed his wife Julie was addicted to pain medication, and that she made unauthorized purchases which her husband was trying to prevent.

Julie Harper pleads not guilty to murder, and personal use of a handgun, for which she could get 50-years-to-life in prison. Julie Harper is held in lieu of $2 million bail, and is next due in court in February.

  • News Ticker alerts


Visduh Dec. 14, 2012 @ 10:21 a.m.

Her father is getting very lenient treatment, since he could have been charged as an accessory after the fact, and maybe a co-conspirator. She's in deep doo-doo. If she wanted to use self-defense as her excuse, she would have immediately called 911 within seconds of the shooting. But she left the house and presumably let him die without any aid. But now that her dad is immunized from prosecution, he has to tell the truth and answer any/all questions put to him. That may prove to be a good move on the part of the DA.

Even the "brilliant" Pfaul Pfingst will be hard pressed to get her off. He hasn't done so well lately with some of his cases.


SurfPuppy619 Dec. 14, 2012 @ 12:21 p.m.

I think since she had no arrest warrant at the time her father had her in his home he could not have been charged with accessory after the fact, and even if she did have an arrest warrant the father would still have to have knowledge of it to be aware she was wanted for a criminal act.......all I know is this idiot killed the father of her children (at least not in front of the children) and will probably get 25-life if she is convicted, which eaves her children orphaned.....family issues run deep and emotions in them run high, it never helps the children.


Sign in to comment

Win a $25 Gift Card to
The Broken Yolk Cafe

Join our newsletter list

Each newsletter subscription means another chance to win!