• Game Day alerts

My father used to say: "the older you get, the better you were." Maybe this is a variation: "the better they were."

Maybe not.

All this bruhaha about Dream Team 2012 (Kobe, Lebron) vs Dream Team 1992 (Magic, Bird) and who would win...

There was no Olympics in 1962, so they never played together. But I would dearly love to see how the all-stars from that season would have done against the alleged dream teams.

Small Forward: Lebron? Meet Elgin Baylor. Baylor averaged 38.3 points per in half a season for the Lakers (served in the National Guard) and 18.6 rebounds. Right before the opening tip, he'd lock arms with his opponent, grind his teeth, and ask, "how you wanna do this?"

Power Forward: Bob Pettit, St. Louis Hawks. He averaged 31.1 ppg on a team with three 20-point scorers. Also 18.7 rebounds. In a championship game against the Celtics he scored 50 with a broken wrist.

Point Guard: Oscar Robertson, Cincinnati Royals. the greatest basketball player who ever walked the earth. In the '61-'62 season, he averaged 30.8 points, 12.5 rebounds, and 11.4 assists (and as Nick Canepa pointed out, unlike today, these were passes that led to a basket).

That's a triple-double every game. Go ahead, TRY THIS AT HOME!

Shooting Guard: Jerry West, 30.8 for the Lakers. Earned the nickname "Mr. Clutch" around this time.

Center: Got a problem here. Bill Russell (who has how many championship rings?): 18.9 and 23.6 and uncounted blocked shots.

Or Wilt Chamberlain, who averaged 50.4 and 25.7 for the season. And if Wilt could shoot free throws from the top of the key, I'd spot the other teams 10 pts. (for two summers, 1962 and 1963 I was the SF Warriors' "ball boy" for their fall practices at San Jose City College. One of my tasks: retrieve the Dipper's free throws after practice. He shot one-handed line drives that boinged everywhere. When frustrated, he'd take a few steps back and fling home at least eight of ten).

Worse comes to worse: put Wilt at power forward.

The bench? Haven't thought that through.

The '62 squad might be appalled at how well the 2012's shoot from deep (in those days, a jumper from over 20 feet made you a "gunner"). Also the athleticism of the current players, especially the taller ones.

Fifty years ago the game was slower. Offenses were set patterns designed to free up mid-range jumpshots. And it was much more lateral than vertical: Baylor went through, not over, you. So did Oscar, any time he wanted.

A final factor: the '62 players didn't act like entitled rock stars. They were all business, Sonny, not personal.

  • Game Day alerts


JEFFREY July 26, 2012 @ 8:43 a.m.

This is a fact! These cats were the best! Back then, they played for integrity. They shot with arc and elbows tucked.


Jeff Smith July 26, 2012 @ 10:22 a.m.

Ha! A believer! It's always amazed me how little baseball has changed. How Abner Doubleday, or whoever, figured 90 feet to be the perfect distance for the bases.

The more I think about my "dream team," I wonder how much the game has changed. There are so few genuine centers - a la Wilt - these days. And Shaq couldn't have carried the Dipper's athletic supporter.

But the great shooter from each era - Bill Sharman, Freeman Williams, Ray Allen - launches from farther out than the previous one. And, and this may be a big difference, nowadays they release the ball a LOT quicker.


tomjohnston Aug. 28, 2012 @ 10:28 p.m.

Bill Russell at center. Better defensively and with the others, you don't need Chamberlain's scoring. An old story about Russell. Early in his career he was getting beaten up inside constantly, They had a nationally televised game coming up. Auerbach told him to throw an elbow on national tv. Russell didn't want to. Auerbach told him to do it once on on tv, where every one could see it and he'd never have to do it again. He did it and never had to do it again. If the two teams played under current rules, even with the 3 point shot, the old guys win. West could shoot from anywhere. Give them a zone defense and even with a 16' lane, much better defensively. Who matches up inside with Russell? Lebron is big, but Baylor was way more physical and having watched the Lakers since the 60's, could be as mean as they come when necessary and set some of the nastiest picks I've ever seen. The old guys would win hands down. Absolutely!


Sign in to comment

Win a $25 Gift Card to
The Broken Yolk Cafe

Join our newsletter list

Each newsletter subscription means another chance to win!