Is photography art?
Here’s my theory: The painter starts with a blank canvas and daubs his version of reality onto it. The photographer starts off capturing reality ready-made, and then subtracts from it in a way that expresses his feelings about it. That’s what it seems like in here, anyway, at the Spanish Village Art Center in Balboa Park. Robert Barry has filled Gallery 21 with photographs — but photos of objects more than of people. In fact, it seems this man can make abstract photographic art out of anything, even a stain in the tarmac.

Right now — this is back in early September — I’m looking at a picture of signs.“Some people are so poor, all they have is money.” “Women Love Quitters.” “If you fail to plan, you plan to fail.” These sit alongside an image of a grainy, alarmed face. Nearby is a triptych of a red stroller, another girl’s face, and a Euro street scene. I guess I'm a sucker for people; I can’t stop looking at the beautiful, concerned face in the middle (which Barry says is actually just a snip from a watch ad).

But consider a photo called “Palm, Tihosuco,” which features an old house in Quintana Roo, down near the Mayan ruins of Tulum, Mexico. Here, as elsewhere, serendipity reigns. Barry has de-emphasized the house in favor of a close-focus of a palm frond that happened to be there. “I took this in a little town of three or four thousand people. It’s got that Moorish architecture, Spanish influence, and obviously the building is old. But the fresh palm frond in the front grabbed my attention. An architect would cut the branch down, but I focused on the palm’s fronds and its green color. It just jumps out at you. I’m kind of interested in the patina of things. The antiquity that you find in old villages down there can go back to the 16th century. And some cities have Mayan, Aztec, Olmec overlays.”

So how come he’s interested in the young, live, palm frond? “If you stood there, you probably wouldn’t even notice that,” he says. “But I edit [a scene] to find the most important thing. My brain just kind of does that. I’m interested in the way things fit together.”
Barry’s having to fit his active life into his wheelchair these days. He’s living with ALS, Lou Gherig’s disease. But it hasn’t stopped him holding this exhibition. “I did my first college photography class in 1977, he recalls, "was a photographer at UC Berkeley, and also Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, then taught full time 1989-2015. I love to do photography most, but teaching is up there. I get to teach the thing I love. It doesn’t get much better than that.”
Now we’re looking at, well, this picture of a stain in the tarmac: This one has divisions that go horizontally. There’s a splotch at the bottom, and then the tarmac, and then some cement that’s all cracked and spidering, with like a watercolor painting on the wall up above. “It’s just the relationship of all those things that don’t fit together,” Barry says. “I like taking the picture and forcing you to see a relationship. I guess I’ve trained myself. I go by, I see it, and I think ‘Oh wow.’”
Is photography art?
Here’s my theory: The painter starts with a blank canvas and daubs his version of reality onto it. The photographer starts off capturing reality ready-made, and then subtracts from it in a way that expresses his feelings about it. That’s what it seems like in here, anyway, at the Spanish Village Art Center in Balboa Park. Robert Barry has filled Gallery 21 with photographs — but photos of objects more than of people. In fact, it seems this man can make abstract photographic art out of anything, even a stain in the tarmac.

Right now — this is back in early September — I’m looking at a picture of signs.“Some people are so poor, all they have is money.” “Women Love Quitters.” “If you fail to plan, you plan to fail.” These sit alongside an image of a grainy, alarmed face. Nearby is a triptych of a red stroller, another girl’s face, and a Euro street scene. I guess I'm a sucker for people; I can’t stop looking at the beautiful, concerned face in the middle (which Barry says is actually just a snip from a watch ad).

But consider a photo called “Palm, Tihosuco,” which features an old house in Quintana Roo, down near the Mayan ruins of Tulum, Mexico. Here, as elsewhere, serendipity reigns. Barry has de-emphasized the house in favor of a close-focus of a palm frond that happened to be there. “I took this in a little town of three or four thousand people. It’s got that Moorish architecture, Spanish influence, and obviously the building is old. But the fresh palm frond in the front grabbed my attention. An architect would cut the branch down, but I focused on the palm’s fronds and its green color. It just jumps out at you. I’m kind of interested in the patina of things. The antiquity that you find in old villages down there can go back to the 16th century. And some cities have Mayan, Aztec, Olmec overlays.”

So how come he’s interested in the young, live, palm frond? “If you stood there, you probably wouldn’t even notice that,” he says. “But I edit [a scene] to find the most important thing. My brain just kind of does that. I’m interested in the way things fit together.”
Barry’s having to fit his active life into his wheelchair these days. He’s living with ALS, Lou Gherig’s disease. But it hasn’t stopped him holding this exhibition. “I did my first college photography class in 1977, he recalls, "was a photographer at UC Berkeley, and also Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, then taught full time 1989-2015. I love to do photography most, but teaching is up there. I get to teach the thing I love. It doesn’t get much better than that.”
Now we’re looking at, well, this picture of a stain in the tarmac: This one has divisions that go horizontally. There’s a splotch at the bottom, and then the tarmac, and then some cement that’s all cracked and spidering, with like a watercolor painting on the wall up above. “It’s just the relationship of all those things that don’t fit together,” Barry says. “I like taking the picture and forcing you to see a relationship. I guess I’ve trained myself. I go by, I see it, and I think ‘Oh wow.’”
Comments