Many low-income and unhoused San Diegans whose cars have been towed by the city have ended up losing their means of transportation — and sometimes, their homes.
A 2022 performance audit of the city’s towing program found the top reasons for towing were expired registration over six months, unpaid tickets, and 72-hour parking violations. These are all known as “poverty tows," because they’re three to five times more likely to result in a lien sale.
Each year, the San Diego Police Department authorizes the towing of approximately 20,000 vehicles, and while the number of overall tows has decreased, the number of these “disproportionate impact tows” has not.
Now the city is looking at ways to reduce unfair towing, even as a towing fee increase approved in March may lead to more lien sales as vehicle owners face hefty debts.

On November 12, the public safety committee will vote to adopt changes to the city policy that has led to a larger share of low-income and unhoused people losing their vehicles. It has also led to the city’s towing program — intended to keep streets clear for public parking and street sweeping — being unable to recover its costs.
The area with the most tows — 4344 — is District Three, which covers Downtown San Diego, Hillcrest, North Park, Balboa Park, Bankers Hill, Mission Hills, University Heights, and Normal Heights. District Eight neighborhoods such as Barrio Logan, San Ysidro, and Otay Mesa were next, with 2992 tows.
To reduce poverty tows, the amendments will state that the city's policy is to issue citations (rather than to tow) for vehicles with registrations expired for more than six months.
Currently, the city offers a low-income payment plan for parking citations — but not for towing. As of July 1, 2025, the city’s total impound fees are $250. That’s not counting whatever fees the towing company tacks on, which can include storage, after-hours pickup, administrative and processing fees, and even clean-up charges.
Other proposed changes would require the San Diego Police Department, which oversees the towing program, to report on its performance at least once every three years, including the total number of tows and vehicles sold via lien sales, all broken out by tow reason.
To follow up on how well the amendments are working, the committee will receive a report from the office of the independent budget analyst before the end of fiscal year 2027.
In past years, the towing program’s income from administrative fees fell far short of covering its labor costs. (Compared with four other local jurisdictions, the city’s towing and storage rates are the lowest, a city report says.) Despite auctioning thousands of vehicles, the city loses $1.5 million per year on the program. And lien sales recover only a fraction of the costs.
According to the IBA office, the amendments could help. Possible benefits to the city could be officers spending less time waiting for tow trucks and an easier task of collecting citation revenue, compared to impound fees. Towing fee hikes the city council approved in March are another way to scrape back funds for the program. The office also believes the tow fee increases totaling an additional $104 payments could result in an increase in lien sales due to the larger amount owed by the vehicle owner.
Many low-income and unhoused San Diegans whose cars have been towed by the city have ended up losing their means of transportation — and sometimes, their homes.
A 2022 performance audit of the city’s towing program found the top reasons for towing were expired registration over six months, unpaid tickets, and 72-hour parking violations. These are all known as “poverty tows," because they’re three to five times more likely to result in a lien sale.
Each year, the San Diego Police Department authorizes the towing of approximately 20,000 vehicles, and while the number of overall tows has decreased, the number of these “disproportionate impact tows” has not.
Now the city is looking at ways to reduce unfair towing, even as a towing fee increase approved in March may lead to more lien sales as vehicle owners face hefty debts.

On November 12, the public safety committee will vote to adopt changes to the city policy that has led to a larger share of low-income and unhoused people losing their vehicles. It has also led to the city’s towing program — intended to keep streets clear for public parking and street sweeping — being unable to recover its costs.
The area with the most tows — 4344 — is District Three, which covers Downtown San Diego, Hillcrest, North Park, Balboa Park, Bankers Hill, Mission Hills, University Heights, and Normal Heights. District Eight neighborhoods such as Barrio Logan, San Ysidro, and Otay Mesa were next, with 2992 tows.
To reduce poverty tows, the amendments will state that the city's policy is to issue citations (rather than to tow) for vehicles with registrations expired for more than six months.
Currently, the city offers a low-income payment plan for parking citations — but not for towing. As of July 1, 2025, the city’s total impound fees are $250. That’s not counting whatever fees the towing company tacks on, which can include storage, after-hours pickup, administrative and processing fees, and even clean-up charges.
Other proposed changes would require the San Diego Police Department, which oversees the towing program, to report on its performance at least once every three years, including the total number of tows and vehicles sold via lien sales, all broken out by tow reason.
To follow up on how well the amendments are working, the committee will receive a report from the office of the independent budget analyst before the end of fiscal year 2027.
In past years, the towing program’s income from administrative fees fell far short of covering its labor costs. (Compared with four other local jurisdictions, the city’s towing and storage rates are the lowest, a city report says.) Despite auctioning thousands of vehicles, the city loses $1.5 million per year on the program. And lien sales recover only a fraction of the costs.
According to the IBA office, the amendments could help. Possible benefits to the city could be officers spending less time waiting for tow trucks and an easier task of collecting citation revenue, compared to impound fees. Towing fee hikes the city council approved in March are another way to scrape back funds for the program. The office also believes the tow fee increases totaling an additional $104 payments could result in an increase in lien sales due to the larger amount owed by the vehicle owner.