From time to time, I wonder why I love classical music and opera. I do know it wasn’t a choice. My parents didn’t sit me down and present various types of music and then tell me to choose the one I liked the best and stick with it for the rest of my life. That’s not the way the world functions.
But the fact remains: I have a love of classical music. Why? Why did I listen to Pyotr Tchaikovsky’s Marche Slave, or Slavonic March, on repeat as a sixth grader? I wasn’t a music student. I didn’t have an instrument that I studied. All I had was children’s choir at church, and that only now and then.
If classical music hadn’t been presented to me — accidentally, by the way — what music would have been my favorite? Would I be stuck with '80s Pop, sprinkled with a bit of Yacht Rock? Possibly — but it seems to me that my love for those genres would be based on a sense of nostalgia for the days when my young life was wide open to the world and full of possibilities.
For the record, in some ways, that’s still the case. In some ways, you and I both have as much potential as we’ve ever had; it’s just that our options have narrowed and our time has shortened. Any yearning for the good old days is a yearning for the time when we could do or be anything because it was all ahead of us. The world hasn’t really changed much, for better or for worse. What’s changed is my position in life.
Anyway, the philosopher Ludwig Wittgenstein would chastise me for asking questions to which there are no clear answers. And even if there were, the value of those answers would be dubious. It doesn’t matter why I love classical music. The fact is that I do. Ah, Wittgenstein: always encouraging people not to do philosophy.
The fact is that classical music has given me a lifelong experience of emotional blessings and curses. When you love something, you get angry when you perceive that it is being mistreated. That’s my current position on opera.
I have no worries about orchestral music. It is thriving and remains intact. It is now what it has always been, a group of high-level musicians performing complex and riveting music together.
But opera is not what it has always been. Opera is an experience of theater based on the voice and singing. Just like ballet is an experience of theater based on the body, and puppetry of the penis is an experience of theater based on the — well, you know. (Yes, it's real. No, I am not linking to it.) Today, opera has become something besides a voice and singing-based art form, and I fear that it is in its sunset years.
From time to time, I wonder why I love classical music and opera. I do know it wasn’t a choice. My parents didn’t sit me down and present various types of music and then tell me to choose the one I liked the best and stick with it for the rest of my life. That’s not the way the world functions.
But the fact remains: I have a love of classical music. Why? Why did I listen to Pyotr Tchaikovsky’s Marche Slave, or Slavonic March, on repeat as a sixth grader? I wasn’t a music student. I didn’t have an instrument that I studied. All I had was children’s choir at church, and that only now and then.
If classical music hadn’t been presented to me — accidentally, by the way — what music would have been my favorite? Would I be stuck with '80s Pop, sprinkled with a bit of Yacht Rock? Possibly — but it seems to me that my love for those genres would be based on a sense of nostalgia for the days when my young life was wide open to the world and full of possibilities.
For the record, in some ways, that’s still the case. In some ways, you and I both have as much potential as we’ve ever had; it’s just that our options have narrowed and our time has shortened. Any yearning for the good old days is a yearning for the time when we could do or be anything because it was all ahead of us. The world hasn’t really changed much, for better or for worse. What’s changed is my position in life.
Anyway, the philosopher Ludwig Wittgenstein would chastise me for asking questions to which there are no clear answers. And even if there were, the value of those answers would be dubious. It doesn’t matter why I love classical music. The fact is that I do. Ah, Wittgenstein: always encouraging people not to do philosophy.
The fact is that classical music has given me a lifelong experience of emotional blessings and curses. When you love something, you get angry when you perceive that it is being mistreated. That’s my current position on opera.
I have no worries about orchestral music. It is thriving and remains intact. It is now what it has always been, a group of high-level musicians performing complex and riveting music together.
But opera is not what it has always been. Opera is an experience of theater based on the voice and singing. Just like ballet is an experience of theater based on the body, and puppetry of the penis is an experience of theater based on the — well, you know. (Yes, it's real. No, I am not linking to it.) Today, opera has become something besides a voice and singing-based art form, and I fear that it is in its sunset years.
Comments