Unlucky home is on the left, David Herbert's home is on the right.
  • Unlucky home is on the left, David Herbert's home is on the right.
  • Story alerts
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it

David Christopher Herbert, 36, was ordered to answer six felony counts of animal abuse and cruelty at the end of a three-day preliminary hearing on August 25. The prosecutor said that three of the felonies he faces are considered “strike” offenses.

Photo of defendant David Herbert provided by Oceanside Police

Evidence was presented alleging that since 2012, at least three families who lived in the home next to Herbert’s house in Oceanside had their car tires slashed, or their dogs were injured, and two dogs went missing.

San Diego Superior Court judge Robert Dahlquist also ordered the defendant to answer one felony burglary charge, because in one alleged incident last April, a neighbor came home to 3998 Carina Way and found one of her dogs inside the house had its eye gouged out. Both of her dogs, which were locked inside that day, were also splashed and injured by a caustic liquid, according to expert testimony.

Oceanside police sergeant John McKean reviewed surveillance video

Oceanside police sergeant John McKean testified that he reviewed homeowners’ association surveillance video from cameras that are in the pool area on the other side of Herbert’s home. The sergeant said the video showed Herbert backing out his blue Audi from his driveway on the same day that his neighbor’s dog, named LaLa, went missing. The officer stated he could see the face of that dog looking out the back window of the Audi. No one has seen LaLa since that day, May 30, 2017.

Neighbor Michelle said she moved away a week after her dog LaLa went missing.

DNA from blood spots and dog slobber found inside Herbert’s Audi were matched to two dogs, one was LaLa, the other was a husky named Cocuyo that went missing for awhile and was then found on nearby Camp Pendleton. Herbert has been discharged from the Navy, and his home is about three miles from Camp Pendleton; he still has entry privileges to the Marine base, according to testimony.

Herbert is also facing four misdemeanor vandalism charges connected to multiple alleged tire-slashing incidents.

The defendant is currently at liberty after he reportedly put up $1 million bail in cash. This caused the judge to demand Herbert complete a “confidential financial declaration” because the defendant wants to continue his legal fight with the representation of an attorney from the public defender’s office. His current attorney, James Weintre, protested that if Herbert “ever had any money” he has now “depleted all his resources.” Judge Dahlquist insisted on a financial declaration from Herbert.

Public records show that Herbert has placed his home at 3995 Carino Way up for sale. Herbert purchased the home in 2012 for $376,000, and he is currently asking $549,900, according to online sources.

Prosecutor Teresa Pham asked the judge for a criminal protective order for three named victims, which the judge granted; this order requires Herbert to not contact those persons in any way. None of the named victims are living on that street now, it was stated in court.

Judge Dahlquist ordered Herbert to surrender to the court all his passports, which includes at least one U.S. passport and one Jamaican passport.

Herbert is next due in the Vista courthouse on September 20, 2017, to set a date for trial.

  • Story alerts
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it


jnojr Aug. 29, 2017 @ 7:42 a.m.

I look forward to reading what's done to this subhuman piece of filth in prison.


Eva Knott Oct. 24, 2017 @ 12:41 p.m.

The court system is trying to get David Herbert to pay for his own attorney. Herbert has claimed that all his money was used up, to post one million dollars bail, in cash. In court this morning, Tuesday, October 24, judge Carlos Armour granted Herbert’s request to be represented by an attorney from the Public Defenders’ office, in order to move his case along speedily, as the defendant wants. But the judge also stated that, “The defendant will be responsible for attorneys’ fees after the case is over. The defendant will have to pay attorneys’ fees, because it looks like Mr. Herbert is able to do that.” David Herbert continues to be at liberty as he awaits trial, set for November 22, 2017.


Eva Knott Nov. 20, 2017 @ 6:51 a.m.

David Christopher Herbert, 36, is currently set to go on trial this week in San Diego's North County Superior Courthouse in Vista, California. He is currently at liberty on one million dollars bail, and is expected to appear in department 5 before judge Carlos Armour at 8:40 a.m. on Wednesday, November 22, the day before Thanksgiving. It is unknown if anyone in the court system expects to be able to seat a jury panel during the Thanksgiving holiday, or perhaps Herbert will settle on a plea deal, on that date. Herbert's current public defender is listed as Stacie Patterson, on the District Attorney's website.


Sign in to comment

Let’s Be Friends

Subscribe for local event alerts, concerts tickets, promotions and more from the San Diego Reader