Nathan Fletcher: "I always thought citizenship was entitled to those who were honorably discharged, but I was wrong."
  • Nathan Fletcher: "I always thought citizenship was entitled to those who were honorably discharged, but I was wrong."
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it

A group of advocates for veterans and local politicians gathered in Balboa Park on Monday morning (September 19) to call attention to the plight of servicemembers who, after receiving honorable discharges following their military service, found themselves deported after the commission of crimes.

"Never in my life did I imagine that we would have to come together to say that those who were willing to give their life for our country should be allowed to remain in our country," said former state assemblyman, onetime mayoral hopeful, and Marine veteran Nathan Fletcher. "I always thought citizenship was entitled to those who were honorably discharged, but I was wrong.

"For hundreds, if not thousands of veterans, the system has failed them. Upon completing their service and receiving honorable discharges, many, believing or having been told their citizenship was automatically being processed, went on with their lives."

But a July report from the American Civil Liberties Union points out this isn't the case. In Discharged, Then Discarded, the group looks at 84 cases of veterans who either were deported or face deportation hearings over crimes such as minor drug offenses.

These veterans, the report states, were eligible to become naturalized U.S. citizens while serving, though the federal government until recently often failed to complete the process either during service or shortly after separation. They face further hurdles in often not being able to afford a lawyer (public defenders are not provided for immigration cases) and lack of access to guaranteed VA health and disability benefits after deportation.

"Every American can look at this issue, despite the complexities of our society and government, and know that this isn't fair," said Jack Harkins, a retired Marine officer. "We must take action."

To that end, U.S. House representative Juan Vargas offered up several congressional solutions.

"This week I'll be introducing three pieces of legislation aimed at preventing immigrant service members from being deported and helping veterans who have been deported gain access to health care and services they need," Vargas pledged.

The bills, Vargas continued, would take steps to ensure servicemembers would receive information about naturalization while still serving, establish a tracking system to identify both active and retired troops for the purpose of "fast-tracking" citizenship applications, and allow deported veterans to return to the country on at least a temporary basis to seek health care through the Veterans Administration.

"Some of these individuals qualify for burial at Arlington National Cemetery and yet they can't even come from Tijuana back into San Diego. It's a profound injustice," Vargas concluded.

  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it


Sjtorres Sept. 19, 2016 @ 2:34 p.m.

So if you're an illegal alien that is also a criminal, you should get citizenship or a permanent green card for doing a couple years in uniform? No. I don't think so.


cvret Sept. 19, 2016 @ 5:27 p.m.

the system did not fail them, they failed themselves. they had their chance and they screwed up. many of these individuals were dealing or transporting drugs. good riddance to them.

and it's b.s. to say they didn't know they weren't citizens and thought their paperwork was being processed. I think I would remember if I raised my hand to be sworn in as a citizen and if I had been given a certificate of citizenship.


Ponzi Sept. 19, 2016 @ 7:52 p.m.

Lorena Gonzalez is lurking behind her boyfriend Nathan Fletcher. Guess he's pushing her agenda now. She's disgusting, I hope voters wise up and don't re-elect her.


dwbat Sept. 19, 2016 @ 10:20 p.m.

Looks like she's just standing there, not "lurking."


Ponzi Sept. 20, 2016 @ 10:19 p.m.

Why isn't she next to her man? Making it a pro-Latino/Latina to get felons returned to the U.S.

Remember, service to our country is currently voluntary. Committing a felony means deportation for alien residents. How many of these people were dishonorable discharges? (Many were, why not disclose those facts Lorena?) Lorena Gonzalez is one of the most dishonest politicians to have taken office in San Diego County in decades.


shirleyberan Sept. 20, 2016 @ 3:40 p.m.

And looking for people to pay the diaper bill for families with too many kids.


Sign in to comment

Let’s Be Friends

Subscribe for local event alerts, concerts tickets, promotions and more from the San Diego Reader