• Letter to Editor
  • Pin it

San Diego's Police Department has been slapped with another sexual discrimination lawsuit, bringing the tally to five such lawsuits filed by female officers against the department in as many years.

Denise Mills, a 15-year-veteran of the force, says her supervising officers routinely and repeatedly discriminated against her for being a woman and retaliated against her for taking maternity leave.

The Allegations

Mills, who currently works in the San Diego Police Department's juvenile services unit, says the harassment began in 2009 upon informing her sergeant Martha Sainz that she was pregnant and planned to take time off for maternity leave. Shortly after, Mills noticed Sainz began to favor the male officers and began calling Mills, Dennis rather than her name Denise.

Sainz allegedly began to threaten Mills’s position and said it might not be available upon her return from maternity leave. The stress took its toll on Mills. A doctor later advised her to take 30 days’ leave from her job to alleviate the stress and prevent any potential harm to her pregnancy.

Upon returning from her temporary leave, Mills discovered that her desk had been broken into and files were missing. She reported it to her captain but complaining to her superior made matters worse and the negative behavior from her colleagues intensified.

While recovering from childbirth, Mills received a phone call from the unit's new sergeant ordering her to clean out her office. Mills contacted internal affairs to lodge a formal complaint, requesting that it be handled at the state level and not by the department. Mills was then transferred to another department and the complaint was dismissed.

Mills remained at her new post without any additional complaints…that is, until 2014, when she informed her supervisors that she was pregnant. Her supervisor, Sgt. Gutierrez (first name unknown), allegedly reprimanded Mills for waiting to inform him of her pregnancy. Mills said she waited in fear of having another miscarriage. Mills soon noticed she was being stripped of tasks. She again filed a formal complaint, this time with assistant chief Todd Jarvis. (In January 2015 Jarvis was mentioned in a separate lawsuit for defending what a fellow officer said was a racist cartoon shown during training classes.)

Mills also told Jarvis that she was contemplating whether to hire local attorney Dan Gilleon, who has tried many high-profile cases against the city and former mayor Bob Filner.

Jarvis allegedly responded with a warning that doing so could potentially "ruin [her] career."

Mills’s colleague and former deputy city attorney Angie Reddish Day allegedly compared Mills to "the women who had complained about Mayor Filner and Officer Chris Hays, saying none of those women suffered anything and they just made up complaints to get money."

Mills then hired attorney Gilleon.

Take That, Chief

In a November 19 statement, Gilleon said the problem strikes at the heart of the San Diego Police Department's “good old boys’” network.”

"This case underscores the lack of leadership at [San Diego Police Department], which apparently discounts its obligation to ensure female officers aren't harassed simply because they're women," says Gilleon. "The fact her harasser was her supervisor makes this lack of leadership all the more apparent.

"Second, this case involves [San Diego Police Department's] modus operandi of retaliating against officers who assert their legal rights. I think the fact Officer Mills hired me even though Chief Jarvis threatened her career speaks volumes, both about Officer Mills' integrity, as well as the lack thereof at the highest levels of [the department's] leadership….

"This case serves as an example of the opaqueness of Chief [Shelley] Zimmerman's proclamation of 'transparency.’ The truth is that while Chief Zimmerman is claiming she is cracking down on bad cops, the reality is she's promoting any cop — good or bad — as long as they demonstrate willingness to be one of her 'yes men.'"

SDPD Blues

As reported by the Reader in May of last year, homicide detective Dana Hoover, who also hired attorney Gilleon, sued the police department for sexual discrimination.

According to the lawsuit, her colleagues had shut her out of crime scenes, demeaned her, and made "grunting, animal sounds" whenever she spoke. That case is ongoing. A trial date has not yet been set.

As reported by Voice of San Diego in May 2014, the city had settled three previously unrelated sexual harassment lawsuits for a reported $120,000.

  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it


AlexClarke Nov. 21, 2015 @ 5:52 a.m.

The San Diego Police Department has always been bush league. Even with a female chief there does not seem to be much improvement. Female officers are a great asset but there are still some good old boys out there that can't accept that.


Visduh Nov. 21, 2015 @ 8:50 p.m.

This sort of sex discrimination suit is well known to the Oceanside PD. It seems as if they get smacked with one every year or two. Why that dept still exists and operates is a mystery to me, but hey, plenty of the "stuff" that goes down in that city is mysterious.

The history of the SDPD is one of a bush league department. Many fine people have served in its ranks and have tried to make it the sort of agency the city should have. But the top tier has been wanting for decades now. Hoobler, Kolender, Burgreen, Bejarano, Sanders, Lansdowne, and now this miserable excuse of a COP have utterly failed to professionalize the operation.

When "Kev" gets through with his failed attempt to keep the Chargers here in a city they spurn, he might revisit some of his campaign promises. First the infrastructure needs massive rework and repair. Second, these public safety departments need massive attention. And that needs to start with the police. The department is often a disgrace to a city government that is a disgrace itself.


AlexClarke Nov. 22, 2015 @ 5:55 a.m.

I agree except for Kolender. The problem is and always has been upper management. There is too many sit-at-the-desk supervisors (Lt & above) and too few in the field. Cops are people and most do a great job but you have to have people in the field making sure that everyone is doing their best.


jnojr Nov. 22, 2015 @ 10:49 a.m.

Gee, I wonder why this keeps happening?

Could it be that individuals do bad deeds, and instead of being fired their "punishment" is for the taxpayers to write a check?

Public agencies should be 100% immune from civil torts. Period. There is no valid argument against this. Either individuals should be identified and held personally accountable, or you're in favor of sheltering and protecting wrongdoers at the taxpayer's expense. There is no middle ground. Yes, this probably means that some victims who "deserve" millions won't get it, but life's tough like that. The taxpayer should NEVER be on the hook for the bad acts of individuals.


Sign in to comment

Let’s Be Friends

Subscribe for local event alerts, concerts tickets, promotions and more from the San Diego Reader