Heinrich Schutz
  • Heinrich Schutz
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it

We’re going to go Bach versus Bach here in the second match of Germany’s World Cup of Composers: Johann Sebastian Bach (papa Bach) versus his son, Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach.

CPE Bach was a classical composer as opposed to the baroque style of his father. For a time CPE Bach was highly regarded by composers such as Mozart and Beethoven. It was on the keyboard that C.P.E. Bach specifically excelled.

2014 is the 300th anniversary of CPE Bach’s birth and it will be celebrated here and there. However, birthday or not, C.P.E. Bach will not see the next round as J.S. Bach advances easily.

The next match is the number three seeded Wagner versus Meyerbeer, but that one will have to wait for now.

Instead, we’ll skip to the number-four-seeded Brahms versus number 13 Heinrich Schutz.

Brahms is kind of the Duke Basketball of this tournament. He’s consistently excellent but some people detest him because he’s so bourgeois.

Heinrich Schutz, on the other hand, is from a much different day and age. His era was pre-Bach (P.B.) and he is considered to be the kingpin of P.B. Germany.

Schutz was posted at the court in Dresden from about 1615 until his death in 1672. Of course, the Thirty Years’ War interrupted his work there and Schutz took work in Copenhagen, and also visited Venice where he may have studied with Claudio Monteverdi.

Schutz’s early works were on a grand Venetian scale, Venice being possibly the most affluent empire in Europe at the time. After the Thirty Years’ War there were not enough resources to support the “big event” music and Schutz’s style became leaner and more austere.

His late setting of the seven last words of Christ are among his best compositions and perhaps demonstrate that sometimes less is more.

Brahms, like Duke, is probably bound for at least the German final four and Schutz is out in the first round.

  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it


Don Bauder Jan. 6, 2014 @ 9:53 p.m.

C.P.E. Bach, and his brothers, shouldn't even be mentioned in the same breath with their father, Johann, the greatest composer of all time. Meyerbeer is almost a non-entity now; Wagner is one of the greatest opera composers of all time. Brahms was one of the greatest composers ever; Schutz wrote some interesting music for those interested in the ancients. Final Four: Bach, Mozart, and Beethoven with Wagner, Brahms and Schubert battling for the fourth spot. (I am assuming Austrians are in this tournament.) Best, Don Bauder


Garrett Harris Jan. 13, 2014 @ 10:19 a.m.

Hey Don, ya, the Austrians are next. We've done round one of the French, Italians, Russians, English, and Americans so far. Each country will have one composer go through to determine for all time who is the greatest...as if that's possible. Chopin, Dvorak, Sibelius, and Grieg all got to go the finals because their countries couldn't field enough composers for a meaningful face off.


Don Bauder Jan. 7, 2014 @ 8:02 a.m.

How could I have left out Mahler? He was certainly one of the greatest composers of all time -- say, in sixth place, battling for the fourth spot with Wagner, Brahms and Schubert. And where do you place Handel? He was born in Germany (the same year as Johann Sebastian Bach, 1685, but the two never met). He went to Italy as a very young man and became one of the greatest composers of Italian opera -- but he staged them in London, where he spent most of his life. Is Handel in this tournament? If he is, I would put him in the fourth position. Best, Don Bauder


Sign in to comment

Let’s Be Friends

Subscribe for local event alerts, concerts tickets, promotions and more from the San Diego Reader