My mom: “Joan, you already have two strikes against you. You’re black, and you’re female. You don’t need to be fat, too.”
  • My mom: “Joan, you already have two strikes against you. You’re black, and you’re female. You don’t need to be fat, too.”
  • Image by Howie Rosen

I didn’t know who this poor girl was to be so hated by Jimmy, but I felt sorry for her. I was the lucky girl who got to share a desk with him.

“It’s YOU!”

Kindergarten school photo. During the second half of my kindergarten year at Webster Elementary, my dad would sneak and buy Twinkies for me.

I always made sure that my crayons were lined up just so. My older sisters dressed me in their prettiest passed-down dresses and twisted my long hair into ponytails that only little black girls with “good hair” could sport. My coloring was within the lines — I had faultless technique. And I always gave Jimmy my most rapt attention.

No, no, no, no, no. Not me. I could count, I could put together big puzzles, and countless adults had told me I was cute. He had to mean some other girl. All I had ever done was adore him. He couldn’t mean me.

Joan in sixth grade. “You look like Frankenstein’s wife.” The girl who sat in front of me in Spanish, Sandy, said those words to me, unprovoked.

He turned back to his coloring, and I sat there.

I didn’t cry. I was the youngest of five. I knew better.

I went home and asked for my favorite lunch, a grilled-cheese sandwich. I never told my mother what Jimmy had said. I never told my sisters, either. But I stopped asking them to dress me up and do my hair. I asked my father to cut off my long hair so that I could sport an afro. My mother cried and kept my puffy braid.

I drew a house with a yard and put Sandy's family photos in the windows, drawing black rings around eyes, black gaps between teeth.

During the second half of my kindergarten year at Webster Elementary, we were assigned to a new teacher and a new classroom. There were different tables — long tables shared by six students, instead of the small tables for two. I didn’t sit next to Jimmy, which was fine; he had been replaced by Twinkies. My dad would sneak and buy them for me. I measured everything by them. “Dad, do you love me more than a thousand hundred twenty million Twinkies?” He would say yes, and I knew I was well loved.

Two-day suspension from Pershing Junior High School in San Carlos. Sandy’s parents demanded that I be expelled. They called it vandalism.

The summer following kindergarten is when the Twinkies, now joined by little gel-glazed Vienna sausages and vanilla ice cream, began to show how much I was loved. I was a slightly pudgy first-grader who turned into an even pudgier second-grader. The kids began to tease me. I was always the last to be picked for the kickball team during afternoon recess. No one wanted to play tetherball with me, unless it was to set me up for getting hit. (I was afraid of the ball and closed my eyes when it was coming my way.) I couldn’t twirl on the monkey bars like the other girls.

Current photo of Joan. I want to be sleek, not because I think it will make all my dreams come true, but because it will mean that I will have demolished the fortress I constructed.

My parents watched me plump up. They tried to stem the tide. “Only one egg or one donut or one piece of chicken for Joan.” They encouraged me to eat salads and fresh fruits and vegetables. We started exercising as a family every Tuesday and Thursday nights. My father and I joined Weight Watchers. I swore that when I grew up I would never eat salads and that I would have fried chicken every night (no limit).

My mother refused to buy me girly clothes because they didn’t fit well. I was willing to wear clothes that were too tight, but my mom just shook her head. She shopped for me in the boys’ department at Sears, and my school outfits consisted of corduroy pants and Hang Ten crew-neck T-shirts. She promised me that if I lost the weight, she would take me back to May Company and buy me girly clothes.

Most of my youth was spent tomboyishly dressed while awaiting that elusive girly wardrobe.

The first week of school was always bad because all the girls sported newly pressed hair and pressed, new girly clothes. But Easter was worse, eclipsing even the first day of school. That’s when all the little girls got to dress up lacy and frilly in pastel colors, with white stockings and white patent-leather shoes with buckles. I could wear the shoes. I tried them on, not caring about having to grunt and twist awkwardly to buckle the straps, but they didn’t work with my Tough-skins jeans and flannel shirts.

In fourth grade, my mom called me into her bedroom. I didn’t know what I’d done, but I thought if I started crying in advance, she’d go easy on me. She sat me on her bed and held my hands. “Joan, you already have two strikes against you. You’re black, and you’re female. You don’t need to be fat, too.”

It was like I had parasites, things crawling inside of me, and I couldn’t do anything about it.

Black and female: two things about me that were bad, two things that I couldn’t change or fix. Being fat — or not being fat — didn’t change that I was black, didn’t change that I was female.

Nothing could.

All I wanted to do was eat.

I went from chubby to fat inside of a year.

I withdrew from other kids and began taking refuge in TV shows, especially my favorite, The Brady Bunch, where I could be any one of three very lovely girls. TV was later replaced with romance books, where I could be the beautiful, skinny, white, semi-helpless heroine, with men vying for my affections — cherishing me, rescuing me — all while eating Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. This made up for my real life.

I took refuge in being smart.


San Diego, California, 1977. Pershing Junior High School. Not 1957. Not Little Rock, Arkansas.

That’s the spray-painted greeting that met the first group of black kids bused to Pershing. I was on that bus, a participant in a voluntary ethnic-integration program that had been implemented in time for my introduction to middle school.

I wanted to fit in. I wanted to prove that I was smart. I wanted to be good.

But every day I wanted to fight somebody because “Niggers go home” was always in the air.

“You look like Frankenstein’s wife.”

The girl who sat in front of me in Spanish, Sandy, was pretty and popular and one of the local girls. She had turned around in her orange plastic desk chair and said those words to me, unprovoked. The whole class laughed. The teacher, Ms. Lundquist, did nothing. I was alone and without protection in the land of Lord of the Flies.

More from SDReader


lulutxu Dec. 6, 2012 @ 9:36 a.m.

Such a well written and at times heart breaking story. Thank you for sharing your experiences and providing inspiration.


qpodad Dec. 6, 2012 @ 11:31 a.m.

Ms. Jackson, you write eloquently and with great passion. One of the best articles I have read in a while. Thank you for your candor and strong spirit, and best of luck with your new endeavor.


cqc3 April 16, 2013 @ 2:59 p.m.

The interesting thing about this story is that as much as it is about discrimination, it's also about how one chooses to perceive oneself. I didn't know Joan, but I was two years ahead of her at PJHS and PHHS, and I was also bussed from Southeast. Funny thing: I experienced more racism from other black students than I ever did from whites. Maybe I just didn't notice because I expected it from white students, but to many of the black students I wasn't black enough. I earned the nickname "the professor" from a kid at my bus stop in 7th grade because I dared to speak proper English (i.e., even then, I "sounded white.") Although I assumed everyone at school knew I was bussed, I don't remember it being nearly as big a deal to my fellow students as it was to me; although internally I felt the sting of being an outsider, to this day, many still express surprise that I didn't live in San Carlos, Del Cerro, or Allied Gardens. But my drive to succeed in life was fueled as much by the enormous homes and exotic cars I saw from the window of the school bus as it snaked up Madra drive as it was a feeling that I could be just as successful as any other kid at PHHS . I made many lifelong friends there who ultimately didn't care what color I was. I went on to study at USC and attended law school at UC Berkeley, and am now a Superior Court Judge (with dreadlocks) for LA County, all because I knew that nothing could limit my dreams except me. My senior quote was "If my mind can conceive it and my heart can believe it, I know I can achieve it." I wish I could have shared that wisdom with Joan; maybe it could have helped her to avoid some of the pain she allowed others' perceptions to inflict on her. Because it's less about your appearance than your attitude. Much less.


Sign in to comment

Win a $25 Gift Card to
The Broken Yolk Cafe

Join our newsletter list

Each newsletter subscription means another chance to win!