• Feast! alerts

The Marine Room doesn't try to keep up with the new kids. This 70-year-old restaurant sees no need to trade in its white tablecloths for reclaimed wood; it has no interest in forgoing its soft white shell sconces for those trendy industrial Restoration Hardware fixtures (like this one, which can be spotted at Craft & Commerce, Brooklyn Girl, Rubicon Deli, and even my own dining room at home).

While other restaurants are busy reinventing and rebranding, the Marine Room remains steadfast, offering the same formal dining experience it has worked to hone since its inception prior to World War II.

I've known of this old dining-by-the-sea dog for most of my life. I've been mesmerized by photos of the ocean water coming right up to the giant windows lining one entire wall. I'd even tasted Executive Chef Bernard Guillas's high-end, exquisite fare at foodie events and cook confabs. But the other night was the first time I'd actually stepped foot inside his domain. Walking down the staircase toward the lounge to the left and the dining room to the right, I was reminded of dining scenes from the movie, the Titanic.

David and I were led to a table by an older gentleman wearing a suit. The lounge was packed. We later heard live music, a woman singing, and viewed the lounge happy hour menu, which explained the disproportionate crowd in the lounge versus the dining room, at least before 6 p.m. After that, the dining room was as full as the lounge. Because we had early reservations, we scored a table by the window, giving us a front-row view of the waves lapping at the shoreline.

I was delighted to find portotonic on the cocktail menu, but regrettably, our server informed me that the bar was out of port. I ended up enjoying a refreshing concoction with gin, champagne, and St. Germain.

David and I opted to share an appetizer, the Cypress Grove Humboldt Fog Brûlée. The kitchen split the dish for us, and we were impressed with the lovely presentation. Because each of our plates came with a small ramekin of the brûléed cheese, it seemed the kitchen was well prepared for sharers. The butter lettuce was lightly dressed with agrodolce sherry dressing (spelled "agridolc" on the menu, which might be French, but I'm only familiar with the Italian spelling), which is a sweet (dolce) and sour (agro) style dressing. Mirroring the salad, the plum coulis on the plate was the right amount of figgy sweet to balance the sour goat cheese.

David ordered what he later referred to as the "beautiful" Free Range Veal Tenderloin, served with truffle corn cake, apple beignet, maitake (mushroom), and Elysium black muscat (a dessert wine we happened to have at home). It was not only a very nice piece of veal, it was a generous portion, and perfectly cooked.

I've been on a steak kick lately (I must be low on iron or something), so I ordered the Center Cut Angus Filet Mignon. Similarly to David's dish, my meat was excellently executed -- a perfect medium -- and the accompaniments (porcini potato, huckleberry chutney, blue cheese, and cabernet franc reduction) served to highlight the steak's natural flavors.

We saved just enough room to share a dessert. I didn't try to pronounce it, I just said "the pyramid thingy," but the official menu name is Feuillentine Gianduja Crunch Pyramid. Again, we were treated to artistic plating. The pyramid was soft dark chocolate with a crunchy hazelnut base, its richness cut by the rose pomegranate consomme, berries, and caramel sauce.

By this time, the sun had set, but flood lights allowed us to continue to watch the water. As we were finishing our last bites, a siege of sandpipers swept along the shore, to set about finding their own version of dinner.

The Marine Room

2000 Sprindrift Drive, La Jolla

(866) 644-2351

  • Feast! alerts

Comments

monaghan April 1, 2013 @ 2:14 p.m.

Barbarella, this was a wonderful dining-out story with great photos that did justice to the elegant presentations of the Marine Room. Can you give lessons to restaurant reviewer Ian Pike? Are those David's pix or yours?

0

Barbarella Fokos April 1, 2013 @ 3 p.m.

Thank you, glad you liked the piece and pics. These photos were taken by me, though a few of the photos in my most recent post (about the restaurant in Baja) were taken by David. We're a team. :)

0

MsSheree April 2, 2013 @ 7:35 a.m.

I've never dined at the Marine Room although I know it to be an icon of fine restaurants in La Jolla. After reading your piece I think I need to drag my hubby off the couch for what appears to be an extradoinary dining experience. Thanks for the tip.

0

Barbarella Fokos April 2, 2013 @ 9:04 a.m.

My pleasure. I hope you enjoy you enjoy the time travel as much as I did. :)

0

Duhbya April 3, 2013 @ 5:15 a.m.

I'm just a bit surprised that the report makes no mention of the Marine Room being closed for 9 months following the strong El Niño storms of 1982. The surging waves crashed through the 3/4" tempered window panes, flooding the restaurant, resulting in a major remodeling project. It is indeed a marvelous (and romantic) place to dine. Thanks for the accompanying photos.

None

0

Sign in to comment

Join our
newsletter list

Enter to win $25 at Broken Yolk Cafe

Each newsletter subscription
means another chance to win!

Close