• Story alerts
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it

— From bubble bailout to debt deflation? That would be the most dangerous fallout from the bursting real estate bubble. The doomsday scenario isn't likely, but San Diegans must face grim facts: the steady rise in home values, one of the steepest in the nation, is over. People went deeply and dangerously into debt to buy homes they couldn't afford. Rising home values bailed them out for years. No more. Sales are down sharply; prices are finally edging down. Now the risk is debt deflation: people cutting their spending to continue paying their mortgage, thus crimping the local economy.

That will happen to some degree, but how much is hard to predict: "We are already seeing a housing slowdown," says James Hamilton, economist at the University of California, San Diego. "We see an increase in defaults; we certainly see price declines. Is this going to be a temporary adjustment or a full-out crash with bankruptcies and panic selling? I just don't know."

July's home sales in the county were down 30 percent from a year ago, according to La Jolla's DataQuick Information Systems. The median price of homes of all kinds in July was $487,000, down 1.8 percent from a year earlier. Detached single-family homes (condos not included) had a median of $560,000, the same as a year ago. Some sellers of downtown condos are already taking a haircut of 10 percent or more. These quoted prices are deceivingly high because sellers often won't go below a certain price, and carrying costs can eat them alive as the home sits on the market.

It's a stark contrast to the boom days. Between July of 2001 and July of this year, median detached single-family home prices doubled.

The giggle juice flowed, and people took unwise risks to get in on the party -- more so than in other U.S. cities. Last year and this year, two-thirds of mortgages were of the exotic variety -- particularly interest-only or negative amortization. In such mortgages, borrowers' monthly payments can be lower than the amount required to pay off the debt. Thus, the loan balance keeps rising, and home values must rise, too, to keep the borrower afloat. These mortgages can be one-way tickets to perdition.

The zooming real estate values didn't only rescue crapshooters; they helped bail out average San Diego families writhing in a cost-income squeeze. High and rising home prices induce euphoria and therefore stimulate excessive consumer spending. According to the most recent report by the Council for Community and Economic Research, San Diego's cost of living is 43 percent higher than the nation's. But incomes are less than 15 percent higher. For decades, San Diegans have had their heads in a vise.

The national savings rate is a horrifying minus 1.7 percent. In 1980, it was plus 12 percent. The savings rate isn't calculated for individual metro areas, but it's a good bet that San Diego's is below the national percentage.

For merchants, the big rise in home values in this century was a mixed blessing. Yes, people bought more furniture and appliances when they moved into new homes, and the wealth effect boosted all kinds of spending. But as prices soared, affordability plummeted; households with median incomes of almost $65,000 a year can afford a mere 4.6 percent of homes on the market. This is one of the reasons that the county's population began declining last year. Home buyers in hock above their heads are spending an inordinately high percentage of their incomes servicing their mortgages; that, too, hurts local businesses.

As home prices rose, more and more people borrowed against the inflated value of their houses. The big question is how much of that phantom financing went for everyday expenses. If people were borrowing against bloated home values to buy their groceries, household goods, cars, and the like, then the economy will suffer when the tap dries up, as it is already starting to do. Unfortunately, there aren't reliable statistics showing where that borrowed money went.

Alan Gin, economist at the University of San Diego, doubts that much borrowed money went to finance local consumption. He thinks the bulk of it "was plowed into move-up housing. Somebody bought a $200,000 home; then they went to a $500,000 one, then to a $750,000 home. They just reinvested in higher-priced homes. They fueled a lot of the housing boom."

Now what happens? New housing will be whacked, says Gin. "As prices reverse, construction will reverse," agrees Ross Starr, economist at the University of California, San Diego. That will hurt. Right now, 7.27 percent of San Diego's jobs are in construction, according to the San Diego Association of Governments. That's up from 6.21 percent in 2002. Another 1.81 percent of local jobs represents people working in real estate offices, up from 1.67 percent in 2002.

So that means 9.08 percent of total jobs are in real estate, but that's only part of the story. That percentage does not capture mortgage bankers and brokers -- and the county is full of them now -- or real estate entrepreneurs working on their own. It's possible that close to 12 percent of San Diegans work in real estate one way or another. By contrast, a mere 1.7 percent work in biotech and 1.2 percent in computers and electronics. "The entire country is vulnerable," but San Diego more so because its economy has been so dependent on real estate inflation, says Gin.

Edward Leamer, director of the Anderson Forecast at the University of California, Los Angeles, says the U.S. economy "will muddle along for several years" because of the real estate falloff, and San Diego's muddle may be stickier. Prices on both coasts soared much more than inland. Among coastal cities, San Diego was a highflier. Now we're seeing the reverse. In July, San Diego's prices actually declined; in other Southern California cities, they were still rising, albeit barely, notes Leamer. Also, the percentage of San Diegans working in real estate is higher than in other metro areas, he says. Still, he does not expect a recession in the United States or in San Diego.

  • Story alerts
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it

More from SDReader

More from the web

Comments

Sign in to comment

Join our
newsletter list

Enter to win $25 at Broken Yolk Cafe

Each newsletter subscription
means another chance to win!

Close