Sloppy seconds? Ken Scott gets another shot at his high concept
Matthew Lickona 1:15 p.m., May 22
Vindication for the grainy, jiggly image of the handheld camcorder, the mockumentarist’s best friend and a corner-cutting, cost-cutting device for any purpose. The premise — the excuse — is the making of a video souvenir at the going-away party for a Manhattan yuppie, the night before his departure to a plum job in Japan; and the product, by its very nature, is an exercise in subjective camerawork as extreme as, though not as strained as, Robert Montgomery’s anomalous Lady in the Lake, 1946. Amateurish by design, with the camera in the hands of a conscripted novice, the evolving souvenir is all we get for the first twenty minutes of the movie, leading to suspicions of padding in what turns out to be barely an hour-and-a-quarter movie. It might have led also to squirms of impatience if the document had not been labelled at the top as the property of the Department of Defense, retrieved from the “area formerly known as Central Park.” You know something’s coming. What finally comes at the twenty-minute mark, revealed bit by bit, fleeting glimpse by sidelong glance, proves to be a distant relative of Godzilla — the yuppie didn’t have to go to Japan; Japan came to the yuppie — a composite creature combining on a gargantuan scale the slimy squid, the plucked chicken, and the skinned calf, shedding like fleas some spidery creatures of more human dimension. (Additional aerial footage from a cable news network lends some helpful perspective.) It is quite understandable and quite realistic, in the post-Rodney King era, that the party videographer would choose to keep the tape rolling as his small circle of friends fights to survive the night (“People are gonna wanna know how it all went down”), and the shaky, sketchy coverage of the events only enhances their immediacy and intensity. And the monsters themselves, even allowing for their extended tendency to play peek-a-boo, are expertly realized. This is Blair Witch on a looser budget. Lizzy Caplan, Jessica Lucas, T.J.Miller, Michael Stahl-David, Mike Vogel, Odette Yustman; directed by Matt Reeves. 2008.
— Duncan Shepherd
Comments
Jay Allen Sanford Sept. 10, 2009 @ 8:18 p.m.
Cloverfield
Cloverfield FAR exceeded my expectations! It wasn't an A-plus effort but, having heard nothing but "yuck" reviews, I was amazed I liked it as much as I did. Perhaps the whole jiggly camera thing isn't so annoying on a little screen - I imagine in a theater I would have needed dramamine pills to handle all the jerking around.
But on a TV screen, I thought it was a unique and entertaining way to tell a story - showing a huge event like a monster tearing down NYC, but focused thru a tiny handheld camera lens.
I watched the making-of docus too, and they were also entertaining, especially to realize how much of the "script" was improvised by actors who weren't even told what the movie was about yet - like the Blair Witch concept, but done far batter and backied with really terrific special FX.
I like that the movie doesn't cheat you out of at least one long, slow, intensely closeup look at big ol' Clover.
Far better movie than I was expecting -- tho I still refuse to watch Lost, JJ Abrams is fast becoming one of my favorite count-on Hollywood powerhouses.
krikor1963 Sept. 13, 2009 @ 1:52 p.m.
Cloverfield
My cousin Neville Page created the Monster in Cloverfeild, check out the 'Special Features" section on the DVD. JJ Abrams is one of the most creative talents in Hollyweird today.
Gregory Page
Sign in to comment
Or login with:
OpenID