• Story alerts
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it

Jimenez said that he is on probation for possession of marijuana for sale. Investigators had recovered from the Nissan a plastic bag holding 4.7 grams of marijuana. Jimenez said the bag did not belong to him and he hadn’t given it to Sudac.

The Defense

During the trial, defense attorney Herb Weston suggested that the driver of the Ford fell asleep or was “inattentive” or that “for whatever reason” he was the one who lost control of his vehicle and smashed into the center divider. Weston proposed that it was the Ford that careened back out into lanes and caused a collision with the Nissan driven by Sudac. The defense attorney vigorously questioned highway patrol investigators. Weston said there were no fragments of broken taillights photographed where the investigators claimed the collision occurred.

Weston suggested that statements made by the driver of the Ford were too influential on investigators. “Maybe your theory is wrong,” he suggested to officers who testified.

Investigators said that the trailer hitch on the back of the Ford had made an obvious indentation in the Nissan, visible in photos taken of the front of the Nissan. Investigators documented the tire marks, which progressed for hundreds of yards down the freeway, climbing up onto the center divider and then back down onto the pavement in more than one place.

Weston called to the stand his own forensic expert and traffic accident reconstructionist, Stephen Plourd, who found fault with the highway patrol’s investigation and conclusions.


Sudac turned 30 years old on April 20, 2011, a day when the jury was being selected.

The seven men and five women heard evidence for two weeks from more than 30 witnesses. They deliberated a full day before finding Sudac guilty of felony vehicular manslaughter and felony hit-and-run causing death.

Sudac had been free on bail, but on May 5, the day of the verdict, he was taken into custody.

Naomi, the daughter of the woman who was crushed to death, turned eight years old this month. On September 9, John Francis Sudac Jr. will be sentenced. He could get a maximum of 11 years in state prison, but he is eligible for good-conduct credits and could serve only half his sentence, according to the prosecutor. Villaflor said, “I’m pleased that the jury reached a just verdict and Sudac is being held accountable for what he did. But it’s never going to bring back Yine Gonzalez and her baby.”

Judge Runston Maino said at an earlier hearing, “Just for the record, I have heard some evidence that the woman who died was pregnant, and that appears to be six months pregnant. That, of course, means that you have another potential victim there. But whether the DA charges it is not up to me, but it’s there if you want to.”

The district attorney’s office did not bring charges for the unlawful killing of the unborn baby.

  • Story alerts
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it


SurfPuppy619 June 21, 2011 @ 8:08 p.m.

DNA tests showed that the blood on the driver’s airbag in the Nissan belonged to Sudac.

=========== BAM, case closed.


RMP July 11, 2011 @ 5:54 p.m.

Thank God so many witnesses were able to validate the officers findings. 11 years is an insult for the murder of that mother and her baby. Thank you officers Holt and Bush for your efforts and dedication to protect and serve.

Also a huge thank you to Timothy Ricker, Solomon Huss, Thomas Harley, Sean Wax, and Zach Thomas for stopping to help. I'm sure your hearts are heavy at the loss of the mother and her unborn baby but know that you probably saved the rest of the family from becoming statistics.


Eva Knott Jan. 12, 2012 @ 4:50 p.m.

The jury declared Sudac guilty of felony vehicular manslaughter and felony hit-and-run causing death on May 5 2011. His sentencing has been delayed many times. He remains in local custody. The current court date set for sentencing is March 9 2012, before the same judge who heard his trial, Honorable Runston Maino. Posted by Eva Knott


Sign in to comment

Win a $25 Gift Card to
The Broken Yolk Cafe

Join our newsletter list

Each newsletter subscription means another chance to win!