• Story alerts
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it

The last of the regular Louisiana choices is red beans and rice, an abomination. This dish started as a Monday washday dinner because it simmers without much attention for hours, while Mama’s at the washateria. The beans are cooked at leisure with some type of fatty, smoky pork (smoked hocks, leftover hambone, or, for the health-conscious, smoked turkey wings) until their liquid tastes deep and rich, not just beany, but smoky and meaty. Before serving, additional pork products (whole or chopped-up sausages, chunks of ham or tasso, even franks) are tossed in to cook in the thick liquid. Red beans and rice has become one of those iconic New Orleans dishes, a staple of local house parties on Mardi Gras Day, cooked in huge quantities and served to guests passing through from one celebration to the next.

At Indigo, no fatty or smoky meat has been harmed to produce this broth. The beans taste as if they’ve been cooked in plain water to be all-purpose ready for, say, vegetarian chili, or other dishes on the menu. They come with those over-fried slices of andouille. I can’t remember whether or not they also had blackened chicken.

Worse to come: We also tried a special of grilled double pork chop étouffée stuffed with shrimp. Paul Prudhomme — NOT. The stuffing proved a dry bread-crumb fluff, with maybe some chopped shrimp in there, but who knows? Who could eat it? The pork was cooked to shoe leather. The mac ’n’ cheese on the side was mild and glutinous. I wouldn’t even doggy-bag the leavings, which was nearly all of it. Emmy took it home for her real canine pets.

I’m not saying that Indigo Café is a bad restaurant — after all, Tin Fork liked the American dishes he tried, and much of our food was edible. If you work downtown, you can sit on the patio when day is done, lounge in the sun, and drink some rum. But if you’re looking for Creole or Cajun food, what’s most remarkable here is its 100 percent failure rate. Have the owners never heard of cookbooks? For a few bucks’ investment, the kitchen could get some education. (Start with the basic New Orleans Cookbook by Richard and Rima Collin, available in paperback.)

The food, at least the Louisiana side of it, works out much like the room: There are pictures of the jazz and blues greats all over but none of their music playing — and nothing remotely soulful coming off the stove.

A Few More New Orleans Cookbooks: all available on Amazon.com.

Cooking Up a Storm. Gathered and issued by the NOLA Times-Picayune, this paperback is a collection of home recipes, restaurant dishes, and newspaper recipes lost to the damage of Katrina but recovered from readers and the newspaper’s files. It’s already a home-cooking favorite of mine.

Real Cajun by Donald Link. This has to be the anti-Prudhomme book, by one of the top chefs in Nawlins, born Cajun, who has taken up making his own sausages, et al. There’s more than that in here — plenty of plain country eats. I haven’t cooked from it yet, just slavered over the recipes.

My New Orleans by John Besh. How to cook like Nawlins’ current top chef.

Crescent City Cooking by Susan Spicer. Another top chef, but her version of NOLA cooking lightens it and brings it up to date with Cal cuisine. Great food, but not traditional.

Tom Fitzmorris’s New Orleans Food. Restaurant and home recipes, large-format paperback. In the few years since I bought it, I haven’t used it. Don’t know why not. So many cookbooks, so little time.

Paul Prudhomme and Emeril Lagasse: Stick to their first cookbooks, before they became celebrities. Both are useful for serious cooks. Prudhomme’s dishes are labor-intensive and scary rich, but that’s just how it is. Emeril pre-BAM! is straightforward, a decent starter to cooking NOLA-style — although the very best recipe comes from his New England childhood, a Portuguese greens, potato, and sausage soup.

Indigo Café

  • 1.5 stars
  • (Fair to Good)

1435 Sixth Avenue, downtown, 619-702-6478, indigocafeandcatering.com

HOURS: Monday–Friday 7:00 a.m.–9:00 p.m., Saturday 8:00 a.m.–9:00 p.m., Sunday 8:00 a.m.–8:00 p.m.

PRICES: Starters, $5–$12; salads, $9–$15; entrées, burgers, pizzas, $9–$19; sandwiches, $10–$13; breakfast dishes, $6–$13.

CUISINE AND BEVERAGES: Dinner menu divided between standard San Diego casual fare and New Orleans dishes. Modest wine list, all under $40. Full bar, creative cocktails.

PICK HITS: King’s Cake martini; Cajun Bloody Mary; popcorn shrimp, fried oysters. Best guesses: regular American food.

NEED TO KNOW: Metered street parking (free after 6:00 p.m.), numerous lots all around. (Please note: Review covers Louisiana dishes only. American dishes reviewed September 2009 by “Tin Fork.”) Atmosphere: come as you are, unless your nickname is Filthy McNasty.

  • Story alerts
  • Letter to Editor
  • Pin it

More from SDReader


rtai001 April 16, 2010 @ 8:29 p.m.

Have you ever heard the term Absence without Malice, well this so called critic obviously did the opposite with Malice!

Lets see, this critic so-called accomplishments:

She has written/co-written four out-of-print cookbooks and an unauthorized biography of Francis Ford Coppola

What is a critic?

1 a : one who expresses a reasoned opinion on any matter especially involving a judgment of its value, truth, righteousness, beauty, or technique b : one who engages often professionally in the analysis, evaluation, or appreciation of works of art or artistic performances 2 : one given to harsh or captious judgment

Why is she building up another restaurant in her second paragraph?

All restaurants have various ethnic personal working in there establishments & even a critic would know they are not the ones who establish the recipes, so why play the racial trump card: The cook looked more likely to be from Nuevo León than from Nuevo Orleans.

As far as drinks to imply that the Indigo Café under pours drinks is totally ludicrous, I seen more guest asking the drinks to be toned down & never heard this complaint whether a Fufu drink or a Jack & Coke. The bar long, hmmm 5 – 6 stools.

The food is not designed to be overly spicy, due to most of the cliental are visitors that like to try southern Cajun food, mostly retired. But if you would like to spice it up a little, there are 50 or more various bottles of Cajun hot sauce at your disposal to spice your food up a little or if you would like your food with a little bite, alls you have to do is ask ! The restaurant is also is health conscious in there sauces.

Looks like this so called critic as a professional strikeout per definition CRITIC.

Just a local, who does enjoy the Indigo Café & shame on you!


phil28 April 16, 2010 @ 9:12 p.m.

I happen to think Naomi Wise writes some of the most well-informed, intelligent and accurate reviews of any food reviewer, including those with national audiences. If the best you can do is criticize her career and then defend what apparently tries to pass for food as being overly spicy, you don't make Indigo any more appealing. Ms. Wise, unlike many reviewers, gets very specific about the ingredients, preparation and taste. She certainly needs no defending, but we're lucky to have her in San Diego. I don't know her, never met her, but do relish finding great restaurants and avoiding the dogs. Looks like she came through once more.


Sheryl April 19, 2010 @ 12:23 p.m.

Whew... if it wasn't for Naomi's reviews -- which I find not only informative but educational -- I would most likely have wasted lots money and time (both of which I value) at some pretty lousy restaurants. If you claim to serve Creole or Cajun cuisine -- then it should be flavorful, spicy and true to tradition. Sadly, one more lousy restaurant to avoid in the Gaslamp.


ckblondiee May 8, 2010 @ 10:38 a.m.

Well, it appears that there is a whole lotta’ rhetoric going on in response to the restaurant review of the Indigo by Ms. Wise. Without going into a whole spiel about racism and discrimination etc., that is showing up in the responses to the review, the point needs to be made that our world has become an appalling place when individuals cannot even express themselves due to these factors. We cannot speak because we may say something politically incorrect according to governmental and societally enforced guidelines, laws, and mores! How ridiculous and very much against our constitutional right of freedom of speech and press. Ms. Wise was not happy with her experience at this particular restaurant. It did not meet her standards. Ms. Wise has a right to express that and the rest of the world needs to get over it! Some of the responses sound like a group of immature spoiled ‘brats’…opps, am I being politically incorrect or stereotypical or discriminatory or racists here…?! I thoroughly enjoy the reviews of Ms. Wise. The reviews are interesting, humorous, factual, and knowledgeable. It must be stated that if some individuals cannot handle playing with the Big Dogs in the real world, this writer’s suggestion is that he or she just fold it up, go home, and hide under your bed! It is a shame that the Indigo did not receive a more positive review. Rather than quibbling about it and slinging mud, why not take a lesson from it and make positive changes to improve.


Bayou Bengal May 14, 2010 @ 4:08 p.m.

I have to agree with Naomi...as a New orleans native and confirmed foodie, I was also disappointed in the Indigo Cafe and felt that her descriptions were spot on. Dont take it personally Indigo Cafe (and fans), just up the ante. Laissez les bon temps rouler!


Sign in to comment

Win a $25 Gift Card to
The Broken Yolk Cafe

Join our newsletter list

Each newsletter subscription means another chance to win!