Most movie critics feel compelled to draw up an annual list. A few years ago, I was amused when Roger Ebert complained that list-making has become trivialized — Roger has shoveled critical coals into the Top Ten furnace since 1967, and this year he even apologized for overloading his list.
But I see his point. In the Web era, one list can detonate the creation of a hundred others. And the variations are infinite: care to know about the ten best Laundromat scenes in Polynesian cinema? Some movieholic grind is eager to tell you. And when a movie shows up on year-end lists, in critics’ awards, and in contest nominations, many people who didn’t care for a particular film decide that they must have been wrong. A faddish consensus takes hold.
But, really, whose taste is best? Your own! These are the movies I liked the most. This list includes more foreign films than any wrap-up I’ve done, and although it’s a top ten, it’s in alphabetical order because no film is quite No. 1.
1) A Film Unfinished. Yael Hersonski’s harrowing disinterment of a Nazi propaganda film made in the Warsaw ghetto. It opens a Pandora’s casket of questions about motive and delusion and brings forth the Holocaust like nothing else in recent memory.
2) Agora. Director Alejandro Amenábar offers a sumptuous staging of 5th-century Alexandria with Rachel Weisz as the scientific pioneer Hypatia. In an unusually brainy ancient epic, her bold ideas glow like dying embers as the classical world expires.
3) The Ghost Writer. The resident phantom is Hitchcock, haunting Roman Polanski’s beautifully made, completely adult thriller. A gullible writer (Ewan McGregor) is drawn into a paranoid fog of state secrets that implicate the Bush-Blair bond and even Polanski’s own legal troubles.
4) The King’s Speech. The shy new king, George VI (Colin Firth), must learn how to control his stammer as Hitler harangues, Churchill growls, and destiny calls. Tom Hooper’s film, more human than royal, achieves a very English eloquence in the alliance of Firth with Geoffrey Rush as his speech therapist.
5) Mademoiselle Chambon. The spirit of Eric Rohmer flirts with David Lean’s Brief Encounter in Stéphane Brizé’s austere romance about a sensitive carpenter (Vincent Lindon) and a demure teacher (Sandrine Kiberlain). Perfection of a kind.
6) The Secret in Their Eyes. From Argentina, un tango de Borges y Hitchcock. In Juan José Campanella’s mystery, Ricardo Darín deals with the past, a rape tragedy, a sexy judge, and corruption. Almost too many plot threads, but they are richly woven.
7) Somewhere. See review, below.
8) Vincere. A temblor shook up my second viewing of this, and the movie still quakes. Marco Bellocchio’s marvel is an operatic, erotic vivisection of fascism and misogyny as Mussolini (Filippo Timi) tries to bury in oblivion his obsessed first love, Ida (Giovanna Mezzogiorno). The voluptuous style is stirring.
9) Wild Grass. More shades of Hitchcock, as if filtered through Tati and Godard but mainly old master Alain Resnais (now 88). He never falters in this odd, tonic comedy about the winking absurdities of time, chance, flight, fate, and film.
10) Winter’s Bone. A gnawing drama about a brave Ozarks teen (Jennifer Lawrence) facing bad choices in a poor, ignorant land. Her visit to a swamp is unforgettable, in Debra Granik’s film about the cost of isolation and bitter blood.
Crowding in right behind: The American, The Art of the Steal, Cairo Time, City Island, Easy A, Exit Through the Gift Shop, Farewell, Father of My Children, Fish Tank, 44 Inch Chest, Greenberg, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, I Am Love, The Jazz Baroness, The Kids Are All Right, Mother, My Dog Tulip, No One Knows About Persian Cats, Rabbit Hole, The Secret of Kells, Shutter Island, Toy Story 3, Vision, Waste Land.
Why not The Social Network? In David Fincher’s coy, verbose, but insufficiently lucid treatment of the founding of Facebook, star Jesse Eisenberg remains (expertly) an opaque and irritating enigma. His character’s slippery games with “friends” inspired this movie’s slippery games with viewers.
Acting laurels: Colin Firth and Geoffrey Rush, The King’s Speech; Giovanna Mezzogiorno and Filippo Timi, Vincere; Vincent Lindon and Sandrine Kiberlain, Mademoiselle Chambon; George Clooney and Violante Placido, The American; Ewan McGregor, The Ghost Writer; Hye-ja Kim, Mother; Nicole Kidman, Rabbit Hole; Ricardo Darín, The Secret in Their Eyes; Rachel Weisz, Agora; Michelle Williams, Blue Valentine; Patricia Clarkson, Cairo Time; Andrew Garfield, The Social Network; Emma Stone, Easy A; Andy Garcia, City Island; Jennifer Lawrence, Winter’s Bone; Katie Jarvis, Fish Tank.
Best ensemble: The Kids Are All Right (slight edge: Annette Bening).
Big mess, big success: Inception.
Animation excellence: The Secret of Kells.
Best genre slumming: Scorsese’s Shutter Island, not the Coens’ True Grit.
Superbly excessive: John Hurt, nasty little devil in 44 Inch Chest.
Zen koan of the year: “Machete don’t text” (Danny Trejo in Machete).
Some movies cast a soft, encroaching spell. Consider Sofia Coppola’s Somewhere, which was given the top prize at the Venice Film Festival and is not, like The Tourist, a cement gondola. Raised in the biz, director and writer Coppola looks into the shallow, glimmering depths of it. In Somewhere, she maintains a suspense of suspended judgment, a palm-leafy mood of compassionate attention, and a hushed, observant style reminiscent of Jacques Demy’s L.A. excursion, Model Shop (1969).
Coppola infuses the Chateau Marmont, a famously hip retro-nest in L.A., with the drifty grace and jaded options of the Tokyo hotel in her Lost in Translation, with the deluxe ennui of her Versailles in Marie Antoinette. She follows film star Johnny Marco, whom we first see zooming his Ferrari in pointless circles. Johnny is played by Stephen Dorff like a stubbled, depleted Jack Nicholson Jr. He will not have Jack Sr.’s career arc.
Attendants hurry to serve, publicists coo adoringly, pole dancers draw his dazed gaze, unfamiliar women offer themselves. Though no dummy (he even plinks a Goldberg variation by Bach on the lobby piano), Johnny is bored by his work, by doting admirers, by dumb questions at a Four Seasons press event (this is not satire). Even sex is becoming a chore, though it includes one very funny sexual moment.